Is the departure of Sigi Schmid a clean break with the ethos that brought Seattle so much consistent success over so many years? What would a comprehensive rebuild even look like? That’s where general manager Garth Lagerwey comes in.

Share story

The Seattle Sounders needed to make a change.

Even longtime coach Sigi Schmid, asked Thursday whether the club’s decision to part ways earlier this week was truly a mutually one, ceded that much.

“It was probably the right time,” Schmid said, after a contemplative pause.

A tenure of 7½ seasons is an eternity in professional sports.

Major League Soccer is a drastically different world than the one the Sounders entered in 2009. Trusted players age. Preferred styles of play go in and out of fashion.

The decision to break things off with Schmid was not a knee-jerk decision, owner Adrian Hanauer said Tuesday, though last Sunday’s limp 3-0 loss in Kansas City might have sped up the timeline. But besides a momentary uptick toward the end of last season, this is a team that has struggled, badly, for more than a year.

The question now becomes whether that move triggers a remodel or a complete overhaul.

Is this a clean break with the ethos that brought Seattle so much consistent success over so many years? What would a comprehensive rebuild even look like?

That’s where general manager Garth Lagerwey comes in.

A season-and-a-half into his Sounders reign and in the wake of one of the most tumultuous weeks in team history, Lagerwey has an opportunity to sketch out his blueprint for the future of the club.

‘No reason to give up on the season’

The Sounders (6-12-2) sit 10 points out of a Western Conference playoff spot with 14 matches remaining. To reach 48 points, the typical demarcation line for postseason qualification, Seattle would have to average two points per game for the rest of the way.

But the news of this week should not necessarily be interpreted as a white flag.

“I see no reason to give up on the season, particularly when we believe that we’re going to get better than anybody else will in the summer window,” Lagerwey said.

The Sounders added Nicolas Lodeiro as a Designated Player on Wednesday and another Uruguayan midfielder, Alvaro “Flaco” Fernandez, as a complementary part one day later. Center back Roman Torres is expected to complete his rehabilitation from a torn ACL within the next couple of weeks.

“I feel very confident in saying that no other team is going to get as incrementally better as we are,” Lagerwey said. “We don’t have to blow this up. Part of the thought is, we don’t have last-place talent. … We’re capable of much more as a group than we’ve shown.”

The next three months could have more bearing on the future of the Sounders than any stretch in the club’s MLS history.

“The ingredients of change have been sown,” Lagerwey said. “We have enough good young players right now who have begun to get minutes that will be that much better next year and that will be relatively inexpensive. That is sort of Course B. Course A, we would love to keep most of this team and continue with it.

“This is the truth: If we succeed and we make the playoffs, then a lot of guys get to keep their jobs. If we miss the playoffs and don’t show a lot of progress, then we’re going to change a lot of stuff.

“We wanted to give this group one last shot. That’s why we’re adding three players (including Torres) in the middle of the season even though, to an outside observer, it might look like a lost season already.

“Right now, the core guys have never failed. So there is no impetus to change them. But there is impetus to push them.”

‘A new beginning’

One does not need to be especially fluent in reading between the lines to get the implication of that last sentence of that quote, nor the second part of Schmid’s answer when asked whether the break was truly mutual.

“I think the first six years at this club, we had a very unique synergy that existed,” Schmid said. “I think every organization will tell you that if you have that kind of synergy, you’re going to be successful. That’s changed a little bit.”

The end of Year Six marked the end of Hanauer’s tenure as general manager, the then-minority owner stepping aside to focus on the business side of the organization.

In his place, the Sounders brought in Lagerwey.

On paper, the marriage made a lot of sense. Lagerwey had helped turn small-market Real Salt Lake into one of the league’s most respected clubs. The Sounders had greater resources and a brain trust that had produced its own consistent winner. Throw it all together, press blend and voilà, MLS Cup.

In practice, it hasn’t quite worked out that way.

Lagerwey took responsibility this week for not moving quickly enough in replacing Obafemi Martins when the star forward left for the Chinese Super League on the eve of this season. Any time a team parts ways with the coach, he said, it is the front office’s fault for not giving him the tools necessary to succeed.

But it had been unclear throughout last summer’s spending spree who, exactly, was calling the shots behind the scenes. Forward Nelson Valdez and midfielders Andreas Ivanschitz and Erik Friberg were all signed from Europe — none of whom meshed with Lagerwey’s oft-cited desire to make the Sounders a younger, leaner team, all of whom came attached with the telling caveat that they’d been scouted by a front office that pre-existed the new GM.

“This team doesn’t play like any team I’ve ever built before,” Lagerwey said Tuesday morning. “I’m looking forward to a new beginning where we have some ability to work on that and build that. … I did my best to be deferential, if anything, over the past 18 months.”

Asked to elaborate a few days later, Lagerwey was even more pointed: “What every manager fears — what they truly fear — is responsibility without authority.

“I just have so much respect for Sigi. And that hasn’t changed. He’s accomplished so much. He’s had such a long career. He’s a Hall of Famer. I don’t know that I would have done anything differently. I think he’s earned that respect. He’s earned that latitude. If at the end of the day, it didn’t work out, then shame on me if I didn’t try. But for me, I did try. I did try to make it work.”

Which way will it go?

So, taking Lagerwey’s hypothetical Course A, the Sounders have three months to turn the season around.

Should it come to Course B, however, this is going to be quite the busy offseason.

It is easier to dramatically overhaul a roster in MLS than it is in other sports leagues, due to the relative rarity of guaranteed contracts. Only seven Sounders are on deals that are guaranteed through next season, Lagerwey said, offering that exact figure but not specific names.

“And don’t get me wrong,” Lagerwey said, “there are two or three more than you’re definitely going to take options on. But on a roster of 28 guys, we have more than half that are going to be out of contract.”

There are a handful of legitimate young building blocks — forward Jordan Morris, midfielder Cristian Roldan, defenders Joevin Jones and Oniel Fisher. Rookie center back Tony Alfaro is still relatively unproven but has been impressive when called upon this season, and winger Aaron Kovar has established himself as a valuable rotation player.

Clint Dempsey remains a central part of Seattle’s plans, Lagerwey said in no uncertain terms, even if he has struggled to carry over his goal-scoring prowess with the U.S. national team into league play.

“I think Clint is one of the best players in the league,” Lagerwey said. “… We’re missing the forest through the trees if we’re picking on him.”

Age is less of a concern for goalkeepers and center backs, Lagerwey said, positions where feel for the game can make up for lost athleticism.

But as for the rest of the group … well, it would behoove them to pursue Course A.

“We’ve hit a low point,” Lagerwey said. “We’ve been a bad soccer team for a year. That’s a crisis. But with that crisis is an opportunity to make things much better.”

A matter of philosophy

There is little question about the chain of command that led to this summer’s pair of midseason acquisitions. The Lodeiro signing, sink or swim, is on Lagerwey.

He did not hesitate to take responsibility for the addition, nor to attach all kinds of symbolism to the attacking midfielder signed from Argentine powerhouse Boca Juniors.

“It’s not just Nico as an individual,” Lagerwey said. “It’s the type of player that Nico is. I think it’s so important with how we want to build this team going forward. … We want the ball. We can drive the game. We can dictate the game. Nico is going to help us do all of those things.”

That Seattle targeted a playmaking midfielder is reflective of a changing league. Look at the short list for Most Valuable Player at this season’s midpoint: Portland’s Diego Valeri, NYCFC’s David Villa, Dallas’ Mauro Diaz, Montreal’s Ignacio Piatti, Sacha Kljestan of the Red Bulls — besides Villa, creative midfielders all.

When the Sounders entered MLS, teams were limited to one Designated Player apiece. Now, each squad can have up to three. The league added the unnecessarily complicated-sounding Targeted Allocation pot of money into the market last summer, encouraging increased spending on players just below the DP threshold.

“From a numbers perspective, the gap has closed dramatically,” Lagerwey said. “If you have five elite players in Seattle, well, you have five elite players at Salt Lake, too. You need to do things differently and more efficiently. There’s a lot less you can get away with. I’m never going to say, ‘You have to play this way or that way, in that system or that formation.’ What I’m asking, for us, and I’m directing, as the leader of the organization, is saying, ‘We need to have an identity.’ From an identity will flow system, tactics, formation.

“Philosophy matters. As the league evolves and the Sounders evolve, those things are going to be critically important.

“We talked philosophically about what’s going to be different. We’re not going to be as reliant on one player. We’re not going to have a strategy where we pass the ball to one or two guys and hope that they score occasionally and don’t worry about anything else. We are going to have systems and organizations and platforms. We’re going to have player successions. We’re going to do it in a way that allows us to succeed long-term, that allows us to plug players in and we’re going to do it in a way that avoids a repeat of the Oba scenario ever again.”

Sounders’ contract situations
A list of 10 notable veteran Sounders and how much they’re making this season:
Player Position Age Guaranteed compensation
Clint Dempsey Forward 33 $4,605,941.50
Nelson Valdez Forward 32 $1,455,000
Osvaldo Alonso Midfielder 30 $941,667
Roman Torres Defender 30 $491,812.50
Chad Marshall Defender 31 $341,666.67
Brad Evans Defender 31 $302,666.25
Andreas Ivanschitz Midfielder 32 $271,250
Erik Friberg Midfielder 30 $262,500
Stefan Frei Goalkeeper 30 $206,250
Tyrone Mears Defender 33 $184,000
Source: MLS players union