Lorena Martin accused the Mariners of racist and sexist behavior after being fired from her job as the team's director of high performance.
After almost three months of investigation by an independent firm, Major League Baseball released a statement of its findings on Wednesday morning regarding the allegations from Lorena Martin that members of the Mariners, specifically general manager Jerry Dipoto, manager Scott Servais and director of player personnel Andy McKay, made racist and sexist comments.
The law firm of Epstein Becker Green “did not uncover any credible evidence” that the Mariners or any of its employees violated MLB’s workplace code of conduct. The firm interviewed 17 people, including Martin as part of its investigation.
Martin’s accusations against the Mariners first appeared via social media posts on her Twitter and Instagram accounts after news that she had been fired after just one year as the team’s director of high performance became public. She specifically mentioned Dipoto, Servais and McKay in her post.
“The Mariners organization has major issues,” the post read. “The things I’ve witnessed and heard first hand have left me shocked. How can their GM Jerry Dipoto, manager Scott Servais and director of player development Andy McKay speak about their players like this. … Calling LATINOS LAZY, DUMB, and STUPID, especially the DOMINICANS.
Most Read Sports Stories
- Inside Russell Wilson's negotiations with the Seahawks: Why the no-trade clause was key
- It's official: In Isaiah Stewart, the Huskies land their highest-ranked recruit ever
- Seahawks 2019 regular-season schedule is set — Seattle will get five prime-time games
- Six (or more) standouts for the UW Huskies halfway through spring football
- With new deal, Russell Wilson has a chance to become greatest athlete in Seattle sports history | Larry Stone
“And then they wondered why they didn’t make it to the playoffs. Leadership is to blame, under Jerry Dipoto’s leadership no team has made it to the playoffs and they will continue to miss the playoffs with him in his position. Poor leadership. It’s come to the point where I have to speak out because they are firing innocent trainers for trying to do the right thing and because of their color/race.”
The Mariners immediately denied the allegations. Following standard policy in such situations, MLB immediately launched an investigation into her claims.
Martin then filed a wrongful termination lawsuit against the Mariners on Dec. 21.
Here’s the full statement from MLB about the investigation:
On November 13, 2018, Major League Baseball announced that it would investigate allegations made by Dr. Lorena Martin, a former employee of the Seattle Mariners, regarding her treatment by the organization and her claims that senior Club officials made derogatory and inappropriate comments. The investigation was conducted by Epstein Becker Green, a national law firm specializing in labor and employment matters, whose attorneys interviewed seventeen potential witnesses, including Dr. Martin.
The firm did not uncover credible evidence that the Mariners, or any of its employees, violated Major League Baseball’s Workplace Code of Conduct, or applicable anti-discrimination law, in the treatment of Dr. Martin or the termination of her employment. The investigation also concluded that there is no credible evidence to support Dr. Martin’s claim that Mariners’ employees, including Jerry Dipoto, Scott Servais, or Andy McKay, made any of the comments attributed to them in her public statement or subsequent lawsuit.
Because of the ongoing litigation, MLB will have no further comment on this matter.
The Mariners chose not to send out a public response to the investigation’s findings. But when contacted, they did release a statement through Tim Hevly, the team’s vice president of communications:
“The Seattle Mariners take allegations of misconduct seriously and investigate them fully. We respect and value all of our employees, including their right to raise workplace concerns. We act swiftly to address all concerns as we did in this case. An outside investigation conducted by Epstein Becker Green on behalf of Major League Baseball arrived at the same conclusion as our own internal and independent investigation, finding no credible evidence of violations by Mariners employees. Due to continuing litigation, we’ll have no other comment.”
Martin was interviewed by Epstein Becker Green lawyer Jennifer Gefsky, former Vice President and Deputy General Counsel of Major League Baseball from 2000-2007. When she worked for MLB, she reported to now-commissioner Rob Manfred, who at the time was MLB’s Executive Vice President, in charge of labor relations for the league.
Around 2:20 p.m. Wednesday, Martin posted a response to MLB’s investigation findings on Twitter:
I am aware of the outcome of the MLB investigation. I am disappointed, but not surprised at the outcome. It is unfortunate that when I met with the Former Vice President of General Counsel of MLB, Jennifer Gefsky, as the “independent investigator”, I provided the names of corroborative witnesses who, to my knowledge, have never been contacted.
It is also unfortunate that she chose not to speak with any of the Dominican trainers who were fired who could attest to the discriminatory conduct. It is also puzzling why the interviews and information obtained is being kept confidential. I would have hoped for a bit more transparency.
More importantly, there were no tapes, no emails, no hard evidence requested nor evaluated other than the questioning of individuals most of whom are still employed by the Mariners. Notwithstanding this decision, I remain confident that the truth will come out and that the damage done to my career will abate.
Seattle Times reporter Geoff Baker contributed to this story.