In Robinson Cano's long-awaited return, the Mariners see ace James Paxton leave with a bruised forearm. Despite a strong performance from Felix Hernandez in his career relief debut, the Athletics take a 3½-game lead over the Mariners for the second wild card.

Share story

OAKLAND, Calif. – I can just imagine the scene on Tuesday when Scott Servais told Robinson Cano he was playing first base in his return to the Mariners following an 80-game suspension.

Cano: “I’ve only ever played second base.”

Servais: “It’s not that hard, Robinson. Tell him, Manny.”

Manny Acta: “It’s incredibly hard.”

OK, I’ll admit I was channeling Scott Hatteberg, Billy Beane and Ron Washington in “Moneyball.” But maybe it’s an apt tableau to conjure up. The 2002 Oakland A’s team so vividly portrayed in Michael Lewis’ classic book (which spawned a popular movie starring Brad Pitt) came out of nowhere to run down the Mariners, who were flying high with a comfortable lead for much of the season before fading down the stretch.

That was the beginning of the Great Seattle Playoff Drought that continues to this day. That would be the Mariners last year to be managed by Lou Piniella before he was replaced, for two years, by Bob Melvin.

Yes, the same Bob Melvin who is now managing the 2018 Oakland A’s team that has come out of nowhere to run down the Mariners, who were flying high with a comfortable (wild-card) lead for much of the season before being surpassed by Oakland.

The 2002 A’s won 20 in a row from Aug. 13 to Sept. 4. The 2018 A’s are in the midst of a ridiculous 38-12 stretch that is threatening to extend the Mariners’ banishment from postseason baseball to 17 excruciating years.

No matter how it turns out, the suspension of Cano on May 15 will be one distinct line of demarcation when the Mariners’ season is analyzed and scrutinized. His return on Aug. 14 will be another – but that long-awaited event on Tuesday had company when it came to potential impact on the Mariners’ season.

Cano had barely trotted out to the unfamiliar environs of first base in the bottom of the first inning when Oakland’s Jed Lowrie hit a wicked line drive off James Paxton’s prized left arm. A pained Paxton left the game – a potentially devastating development for Seattle’s playoff hopes.

Earlier, buoyed by Cano’s return, Servais had said enthusiastically, “I’m excited. I think our best baseball is ahead of us. No question in my mind. The way we’ve swung the bat the last five, six days, has been really good. I really do think our best baseball is ahead of us.”

But take Paxton out for any length of time from a rotation that’s already reeling from Felix Hernandez’s extended struggles, and the degree of difficulty rises considerably – even with Cano back in the lineup.

At least Paxton’s X-rays came back negative (he’s day to day with a forearm contusion), and at least Hernandez had a strong outing in his career relief debut (5 2/3 innings, two runs, a showing deemed “awesome” by Servais). But the Mariners’ 3-2 loss was disquieting on what could have been a turning-point night.

Certainly, Cano was properly contrite in his return, apologizing to teammates (many of whom attended his news conference in a show of support), promising to fill whatever role the team wanted uncomplainingly, and assuring he would not be a distraction.

“It’s not about myself,’’ he said. “It’s about the team.”

It’s a Seattle team that once was 11 games ahead of the A’s on June 16, riding a 100-win pace and sailing toward what appeared to be a comfortable entrance into the playoffs. After Tuesday’s loss, they are now 3½ games behind Oakland for the second wild card, and watching a team that seems to have captured the same magical elements that turned the Mariners’ into the temporary darlings of baseball in the first half. Oakland has supplanted that title and is gaining ground so rapidly – one game behind Houston — that the Mariners might soon be battling the Astros for the second wild-card.

“I think it’s just a total team effort, which can be a powerful thing,’’ Melvin said before the game. “Everybody seems to be involved here, and once you get on a run, and you have the type of confidence when you start winning games, you expect to win. That’s kind of how I see it.”

That’s kind of how Servais saw it, too, when the Mariners defied all the doomsday prophecies in the wake of Cano’s suspension to record the exact same winning percentage (.575) during his 80-game absence as they had before he went down.

While listing reasons the Mariners stayed afloat instead of drowning – strong performances at various times by the offense, rotation and short relievers – Servais also gave a nod to the team’s attitude that bordered on defiance.

“Every team’s got the naysayers out there,’’ he said. “Certainly, Oakland’s overcome a lot of that as well. You kind of put that chip on your shoulder, and when the Robby thing happened, it was still the same situation where a lot of people didn’t think we had a chance. But just keep playing. The whole thing was to focus one day at a time. Stay in the moment.”

Meanwhile, Cano had to watch all this from afar with the complicated emotional baggage of hoping the team thrived yet having to live with whatever feelings of guilt and regret that roiled inside of him.

“It was really hard,’’ he said. “I’m not going to lie. It was so hard watching the game from home, knowing that you should be in there.”

Cano’s return did not have the immediate galvanizing effect the Mariners were hoping for, and now they have the added worry of Paxton’s health. He’ll miss at least one start. The The resurgence of optimism that came out of the four-game Houston sweep has receded after two straight losses to start this showdown with the A’s.

The Mariners will endeavor to stay in the moment. But once again it seems the moment is slipping away from them. I wouldn’t be surprised if the A’s are channeling another one of Billy Beane’s bon mots from “Moneyball:” “When your enemy’s making mistakes, don’t interrupt him.”