The committee, working on a one-year trial basis, seeded each classification for the tournament that begins Friday and was pleased by the results.
For the first time in Washington, the state high-school football playoffs brackets were decided subjectively rather than objectively.
And those involved couldn’t have been happier about how it went.
The Washington Interscholastic Activities Association’s football playoff seeding committee met Sunday at WIAA headquarters in Renton and seeded the 16 state qualifiers in each classification for the tournament that starts Friday.
“This is pretty historic for this state,” WIAA assistant executive director John Miller said. “For so long we’ve been based on that draw and bracket.”
Most Read Sports Stories
- Who won the James Paxton trade? Here's what the national media are saying about the Mariners-Yankees blockbuster
- WSU's Gardner Minshew shows how valuable a grad transfer QB can be to a team. But you'll never see that at UW.
- Like it or not, the Mariners had to trade James Paxton | Matt Calkins
- Mariners trade left-hander James Paxton to the Yankees for three prospects
- A sweet Apple Cup: 'Why can’t you be more like the Petersen boy?’
That draw refers to the way the state brackets were decided for decades as district seeds were drawn and placed on the bracket. Often that resulted in highly ranked teams meeting in early-round games, and there was plenty of fan and coach outcry over those matches.
This new method was approved in June by the WIAA’s executive board for a one-year trial. It used three committees, with each taking two classifications.
“I guess that this point I couldn’t be happier,” said Lind-Ritzville athletic director Greg Whitmore, who is the head of the seeding committee. “You go into these, and you don’t know exactly how it will go. I think all three committees did a great job.”
The committee decided Union of Vancouver (10-0) was the top seed for Class 4A with Woodinville (9-1) the No. 2 seed. Eastside Catholic (8-1) is the top Class 3A seed with defending state champion O’Dea (8-1) the No. 2, giving the Metro League the top two seeds.
The committees, which were each comprised of a dozen people, mostly current and retired football coaches, ranked the field and those rankings were compiled for a starting point. Whitmore said the top four seeds were key as ideally those teams would meet in the semifinals.
Other factors came into play for deciding the next 12 such as keeping teams from the same league apart in the early rounds and taking travel into consideration.
“Our objective wasn’t to seed them one through 16 necessarily,” Whitmore said.
Those in the committees professed happiness over how it went down.
“I thought it was the best thing I’ve seen to be quite honest,” said Heritage coach Matt Gracey, who has coached in three states. “There was a human element. It was a communal effort. You’re not getting one opinion, you’re getting an entire group.”
And now the question is will this committee stay around? The Executive Board will have to vote on that in future meetings, but Whitmore, who is a member of the board, knows how he’d vote.
“If you want my gut feeling, the way it went today, I’m confident,” he said. “… I think it’s here to stay.”