Touchdown catch with a second remaining knocks out the Eagles a game short of the national title game.

Share story

Hunter Wells fired a 5-yard touchdown pass to Kevin Rader in the end zone with 1 second left to lift Youngstown State to a 40-38 victory over Eastern Washington on Saturday to advance to the FCS national title game against James Madison.

Youngstown State (12-3) started the winning drive on its 42 with 4:24 left in the game, and used up the clock as it marched for the score.

Tevin McCaster rushed for 154 yards and three touchdowns for Youngstown State, which will be seeking its fifth national title.

Wells said the Penguins benefited from a bit of luck.

“He was covered, so I threw it anyway,” Wells said of Rader. “He made a hell of a catch.”

“We just find a way to win,” Wells said. “We never feel we are out of a game regardless of the score.”

Cooper Kupp caught 10 passes for 180 yards and two touchdowns for Eastern Washington (12-2), which saw its 11-game winning streak snapped.

“One play doesn’t define the year,” said Eastern Washington coach Beau Baldwin. “It was a battle to the very end.”

“I feel so good about what this group of seniors has done,” Baldwin said.

The Penguins will play for the national championship Jan. 7 against James Madison, which beat North Dakota State 27-17 on Friday. The loss broke North Dakota State’s string of five consecutive FCS titles.

Saturday’s game was played in bitter cold, with the temperature dropping to single digits as the game progressed.

Youngstown State’s Jalyn Powell intercepted a Gage Gubrud pass on the first drive of the game. The Penguins marched down the field, with McCaster rushing in from the 4 for a 7-0 lead.

Eastern Washington replied with a drive that stalled on the 4, and settled for a 21-yard field goal by Roldan Alcobendas.

The Eagles scored again on Gubrud’s 4-yard touchdown pass to Kupp late in the first quarter for a 10-7 lead.
After Youngstown punted, Gubrud connected with Kendrick Bourne on an 83-yard touchdown pass for a 17-7 lead. Bourne caught the ball near midfield and outran three defenders.

Zak Kennedy kicked a 42-yard field goal to cut Eastern’s lead to 17-10 late in second quarter.

Eastern was forced to punt on its next possession but Youngstown State’s Alvin Bailey fumbled the catch and the Eagles recovered. Sam McPherson hit Kupp on a 32-yard touchdown pass for a 24-10 lead.

The Penguins replied with a 69-yard drive, with McCaster running the last 20 yards to cut Eastern’s lead to 24-17 at halftime.

Youngstown drove to the 3-yard line on the opening drive of the second half, but had to settle for Kennedy’s 20-yard field goal. The Eagles replied quickly with an 18-yard touchdown pass from Gubrud to Shaq Hill to push their lead back to 31-20.

Gubrud was intercepted at the goal line by Billy Hurst and the Penguins scored on an 11-yard pass from Hunter Wells to Alvin Bailey, cutting Eastern’s lead to 31-27 early in the fourth.

Eastern went three-and-out and Youngstown State got the ball at midfield. They went ahead 34-31 on McCaster’s 12-yard touchdown run, his third of the game.

Eastern marched 80 yards on its next possession, with Hill running over from the 1 for a 38-34 lead with 4:24 left in the game.

That set up the Penguins’ winning drive.

Gubrud completed 18 of 33 passes for 353 yards and three touchdowns, but suffered two interceptions.

Kupp is an All-America who won the Walter Payton Award last season as the top player in FCS and could become the second two-time winner when it is handed out Jan. 6.