The clinic's high doses — "Take 10 every 6 hours," one painkiller prescription said — reveal murky regulations and Washington state's anemic response.
The first time Alina Heywood accompanied her mother to the Payette Clinic in Vancouver, she didn’t see anything amiss. The place was quiet, her mom the only patient there. The woman treating Heywood’s mom wore a lab coat. Heywood assumed she was a doctor.
But as the months passed, Heywood witnessed a dramatic change. By the summer of 2007, so many pain patients packed Payette’s waiting room that the crowd overflowed into the parking lot. Some patients were slumped over, looking ready to pass out. Others appeared glassy-eyed and jumpy.
“I started thinking, ‘Why do all these people in here look high?’ ” Heywood says.
Most Read Local Stories
- ‘The Property’: A family's getaway cabin defined its dreams, until a tragic Sunday morning VIEW
- Seattle City Council approves $700 million renovation of KeyArena
- Seattle may be warmer than usual this fall, meteorologists say
- Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan unveils $5.9 billion budget proposal
- I-1639 the most ambitious effort at gun regulation in Washington state’s history
Heywood’s mother, Eileen Crothers, had endured pain for almost 20 years. She’d lost an arm after a traffic accident — caused by a drunken motorcyclist — and a botched surgery. When her family doctor retired, Crothers had gone to Payette in hopes of being tapered off methadone, a potent painkiller.
Instead, Heywood says, Payette increased Crothers’ dosage.
On Sept. 11, 2007, Crothers, 48, was found dead in her Vancouver apartment. An autopsy determined that she had overdosed on methadone. She was the fourth patient treated at Payette to fatally overdose that year — and the third death linked to methadone, a long-acting narcotic.
By then, state health regulators had received more than a dozen complaints against Payette practitioners, some involving allegations of dangerous over-prescribing.
In time, the Washington State Department of Health would become aware of at least six overdose deaths of women and men prescribed painkillers at Payette. All but one had taken methadone, a drug the state steers Medicaid patients toward because of its low cost.
Records gathered by the Health Department and others would show that Payette had been prescribing painkillers and other drugs in often extraordinary amounts.
One patient’s pharmacy tab — had he paid full price — exceeded $209,000 in one year, with more than 100 prescriptions for OxyContin and other drugs, according to pharmacy documents.
But despite the six deaths — and despite receiving more than 100 complaints about Payette from pharmacies, medical providers, patients, the county sheriff, the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration and others — state regulators have, to date, taken action against only one of the clinic’s practitioners. And even that sanction took nothing away that she hadn’t in effect already surrendered.
At its pinnacle, Payette prescribed more narcotics to Medicaid patients than any other private clinic in Washington, state records show.
The clinic’s extraordinary rise, coupled with the state’s anemic response, highlights one of medicine’s most bitterly debated specialties, one centered on an ailment — pain — that defies measurement. That Payette stayed open for years speaks to the murky landscape that regulators encounter when confronting painkiller prescriptions.
The clinic’s story also reveals the dangers of the state’s insistence on directing prescribers and patients to methadone, an unpredictable painkiller that can become lethal if used with anything other than the utmost care.
“Too unpredictable and dangerous”
The driving force behind the Payette Clinic was Kelly Bell, an advanced registered nurse practitioner with boundless confidence and a checkered employment history.
Bell, 53, has a master’s degree in nursing from Washington State University and a résumé that includes stints as a nursing supervisor and pharmacology lecturer. She holds strong views on treating pain — “it is my passion,” she once wrote — traceable to her six years as a nurse at the Oregon Burn Center in Portland.
Nurses “are the silent witness at the bedside oftentimes to the callous indifference of a physician,” Bell has written. She described how one patient, with burns on 70 percent of her body, had been denied pain relief despite obvious suffering. “She finally died, horribly disfigured and without any pain medication with a silent scream permanently etched on her face,” Bell wrote, adding: “There should be penalties for the lack of treatment of pain. They should be swift and severe.”
In 2001 Bell went to work at the Clark County Jail in southwestern Washington, helping treat hundreds of adults and juveniles. But she lost that job in 2004 when a dispute with a supervisor resulted in her jail security clearance being pulled.
A month later, in April 2004, Bell went to work at Fisher’s Landing Urgent & Family Care in Vancouver. Within months she started a pain-management program at the clinic. Bell says she was authorized to do so. The clinic’s owner says she was not. Either way, Bell’s practice took off, growing to 40 pain patients.
As a provider of pain treatment, Bell could be both combative and self-assured.
In December 2004, she wrote a letter chastising a health plan that refused to cover a prescription she’d written for an increased dosage of OxyContin, an expensive painkiller. Bell acknowledged that an alternative painkiller, methadone, was cheaper, and that Washington and Oregon encouraged its use in cases where a patient’s care was publicly subsidized. But Bell said she wanted nothing to do with the drug.
“I absolutely will not prescribe methadone for pain. It’s too unpredictable and dangerous and has caused many deaths in both the states of Washington and Oregon,” Bell wrote.
At Fisher’s Landing, Bell had her first run-in with state regulators. In February 2005 a pharmacy manager at Walgreens filed a complaint against Bell for prescribing 2,216 oxycodone pills to a patient in about two months. “I cannot believe this could be for legitimate medical purposes,” the manager wrote to the Health Department.
After receiving the complaint, the state examined Bell’s overall prescribing practices. State officials cited 23 instances of “exorbitant amounts” of narcotics prescribed, but ultimately decided against disciplinary charges, saying there was insufficient evidence to show Bell had violated any specific rule governing patient care.
The clinic fired Bell in March 2005 for “unprofessional conduct,” according to Health Department records. The clinic’s owner told regulators that Bell had been reprimanded for using profanity or abusive language in front of patients.
After Bell’s departure, a physician at Fisher’s Landing re-examined Bell’s pain patients. Many were tapered off pain drugs, which were no longer deemed necessary.
6 deaths in 12 months
After losing her second job in about a year’s time, Bell struck out on her own. In April 2005 she established the Payette Clinic with Scott Pecora, a fellow nurse practitioner whom Bell would marry three years later.
A job posting on Craigslist called Payette “a very unique and groundbreaking practice solely owned and staffed by nurse practitioners,” adding: “This is not a practice for a timid, or lax practitioner … .”
The absence of a physician did not preclude Payette from treating pain patients. Under Washington law, nurse practitioners can receive prescribing privileges, even for such narcotics as OxyContin.
The clinic, on the corner of a strip mall, began attracting more pain patients, reaching, at its peak, about 800. Bell told the Health Department that “probably 50 percent” were on methadone — a surprisingly high figure, given what she’d written about the drug in 2004.
Bell would attribute her about-face to seeing new patients who were already on methadone — and getting the relief they needed. From a practical standpoint, many patients, whether on Medicaid or private insurance, were more likely to get coverage for methadone than for other, more costly painkillers.
To the Health Department, Bell described methadone as a “fabulous drug” but one that was “extremely unforgiving” and “very deadly to work with.”
On Jan. 12, 2007, a former Payette patient, Susan Nelson, died in Clark County, after overdosing on methadone. Nelson, 51, had been prescribed the drug while at Payette.
Nelson had received treatment there for three months, starting in July 2006. At first, she had been reluctant to take methadone, her medical records show. In chart notes, Bell wrote of Nelson: “She absolutely was frightened about trying any methadone whatsoever.” But on a subsequent visit Nelson “finally consented” to start methadone, at five milligrams every eight hours, the chart notes say. The notes added: “I warned her that if she decided to overtake this drug we would be reading about her in the paper because she could very easily die.”
Bell also prescribed Nelson other painkillers, Health Department records show.
Under a pain-management law passed last year, the state calls for extra precautions once a patient’s combined daily dosage of painkillers reaches the equivalent of 120 milligrams of morphine. In this case, Health Department records show, Bell upped Nelson’s daily morphine equivalent from 140 milligrams to 780 milligrams to 880 to 1,170 to 1,440 to 1,800 to 2,160 — all in two months.
Within nine days of Nelson’s death, two other Payette patients also died from accidental overdoses linked to painkillers.
Eight months later, Eileen Crothers died, becoming patient No. 4. Crothers’ daughter, Alina Heywood, says: “I lost my mom way too soon.”
Crothers was treated by Penny Steers, a nurse practitioner who had been hired at Payette in 2006.
Within four months of Crothers’ death, two other people who had been treated at Payette also fatally overdosed on methadone. One patient, Deborah Reid, 42, had been prescribed a combined daily morphine equivalent of 3,880 milligrams — a dosage 32 times higher than the cautionary threshold set by the state, records show.
Kafka or Schweitzer?
In April 2008, state health officials initiated their first large-scale investigation of Payette after being deluged with complaints of excessive prescriptions and suspicious deaths.
DEA agents said a family of three — all patients at the clinic — had received enormous amounts of narcotic medications and paid cash for the drugs at pharmacies, up to $7,000 at a time.
Additionally, state officials from Medicaid and Labor & Industries forwarded “a large number of additional complaints” that led health investigators to the six overdose deaths involving Payette patients.
Many accuse the two women of prescribing dangerous amounts of painkillers — an allegation that would seem straightforward, but can be difficult to prove. When it comes to prescribing painkillers — in Washington and nationally — there’s no universally accepted standard of care.
Until this year, the state explicitly prohibited disciplining medical providers based solely on how many painkillers they prescribed.
With painkillers, two philosophies compete within medical circles. Bell represents one end of the spectrum. The other is represented by Gary Franklin, medical director for the state Department of Labor & Industries, the agency that handles workers’ compensation claims.
Franklin urges caution and advocates limits. He quotes Franz Kafka from “A Country Doctor”: “To write prescriptions is easy, but to come to an understanding with people is hard.”
Bell, meanwhile, writes that she models her life after Albert Schweitzer, quoting him: “Pain is a more terrible lord of mankind than even death itself.”
Bell’s philosophy comes through in her extensive letters to the Health Department. “There is no ceiling on opioids. Period,” she writes. She decries an “unparalleled and unjustified prejudice against pain sufferers.”
“When you compare what I do to that of the ‘regular’ physicians in the community I look to be an ‘outlier’ and ‘out of control,’ ” she writes.
With pain management, Bell describes herself as largely self-taught — saying she reads voraciously about developments in the field — and as selfless, calling the practice “barely profitable.”
Bell, Steers and Pecora declined through their attorney to speak with The Times because of pending Health Department complaints and civil cases. Their lawyer, Donna Lee of Portland, cautioned that state investigative records reveal an incomplete picture of the Payette Clinic and patient care.
The DEA steps in
On Dec. 9, 2008, the death of a teenage girl in a Portland suburb ratcheted up the scrutiny of the Payette Clinic.
Rachel Daggett, an 18-year-old high-school senior, died after crushing and smoking an oxycodone pill. Police discovered the oxycodone had originally been prescribed to a Payette patient.
The prior deaths of six adults on the economic margins hadn’t captured the public’s attention. But Daggett’s death was different. Now, the Payette Clinic was being featured in news stories in Oregon and Washington, lending new urgency to the work of investigators.
By the time Daggett died, the Washington Health Department’s investigation of Payette had been under way for about eight months. Despite dozens of open complaints against Bell and Steers, no disciplinary charges had been filed; nor had either practitioner been suspended in the interim — a power the department possesses.
At the request of the DEA, the state investigation was slowed to give federal officials more time to assemble their own case and to secure a warrant allowing them to gather records from the Payette Clinic, state officials told The Times.
Meanwhile, officials at several pharmacies filed complaints against Payette, including a Fred Meyer pharmacy manager who alleged Bell was engaging in experimental treatment, prescribing morphine for a patient to take home and crush and mix with cold cream and apply to painful extremities.
Some pharmacies began refusing to fill prescriptions written at Payette. On Dec. 29, 2008, three weeks after Daggett’s death, the Payette Clinic sent written notification to its pain patients that Rite Aid and Kmart pharmacies would no longer serve them. The letter directed patients to an Oregon branch of Assured Pharmacy, which has heightened security measures and caters to pain patients.
But even Assured, at some point, appeared hesitant to deal with Payette. Law-enforcement officials rounded up two email messages left at an Assured branch — one by Bell, the other by Steers.
Bell’s message referred to Payette patients being turned away and said: “Quite frankly, if this continues, I’m pulling all my business from Assured, and I’m sure that’s worth about a million dollars … .”
Steers’ message was even blunter: “If I want to order every two hours, I can order it every goddamn two hours. It doesn’t make any difference.”
On March 19, 2009, DEA agents raided the Payette Clinic and seized patient records. Soon after, Bell, Steers and Pecora agreed to surrender their DEA licenses to prescribe controlled narcotics. Unless those licenses were reinstated, the three could no longer write prescriptions for such drugs as OxyContin and methadone.
Eight days after the DEA raid — and nearly a year after the Health Department’s investigation started in earnest — state regulators issued formal disciplinary charges against Bell.
In each of nine cases, the charges said, Bell prescribed “extremely high doses” of narcotic painkillers, placing patients “at risk of serious physical harm or death.”
By the time Bell was charged, the Payette Clinic had been open for nearly four years.
Washington health officials might have detected evidence of aberrant prescribing practices years earlier. In 2007, lawmakers approved a prescription-drug monitoring program, but didn’t fund it.
Since the 1990s, a majority of states have launched programs to track the prescribing and dispensing of such narcotic drugs as oxycodone and methadone. But as of this year, Washington remained one of 13 states yet to establish a working program, according to the Alliance of States with Prescription Monitoring Programs.
Jump-started by two federal grants, Washington plans to begin using a monitoring program next year. For the first time health practitioners will be able to analyze patients’ prescription histories, providing a warning of duplicate prescribing, possible misuse or harmful interactions.
“Take 10 every 6 hours”
In March 2009, the Payette Clinic decided to quit using narcotics to treat pain patients.
“I declare Uncle!” Bell wrote to the Health Department. She recounted all the work she had done on behalf of pain patients and wrote: “We are not a ‘pill mill.’ “
Hundreds of Payette’s former patients turned to hospitals and other pain clinics for help, straining Clark County’s medical resources. Doctors and addiction specialists dealt with the chaos by forming a committee that alerted other medical providers of the need to wean patients off the painkillers.
At least two former Payette patients took to robbing pharmacies, threatening to shoot employees unless given OxyContin.
A Portland law firm, Kafoury & McDougal, filed a string of lawsuits in Oregon and Washington against the clinic and its practitioners, alleging their prescribing practices had resulted in people being killed or hurt.
The lawyers turned up cases beyond those investigated by the Health Department, including that of Thomas Pike Jr., 40, who overdosed on methadone in September 2009. Although Pike had last visited Payette seven months earlier, investigators found pill bottles for morphine and methadone — prescribed by Steers — in Pike’s house and garage. Several medications, including methadone, were discovered in a margarine tub next to the couch where Pike died.
Medical records showed Payette had prescribed Pike a morphine daily equivalent that reached 2,160 milligrams — 18 times the state of Washington’s warning level. One of Pike’s pill bottles, for 1,200 10-milligram pills of methadone, said: “Take 10 tablets every 6 hours.”
The lawsuits against the clinic may go to trial next year.
In December 2009, the Health Department and Bell reached a settlement on her disciplinary charges. Citing a lack of clear and convincing evidence, health officials agreed to drop the language about “extremely high doses,” along with all references to patients being placed at risk of dying. The new, softer language allowed for lighter punishment, which turned out to be a two-year suspension from prescribing narcotics such as OxyContin or methadone.
Of course, Bell had already lost those prescribing privileges when she surrendered her DEA license, meaning the state didn’t take away anything she hadn’t already forfeited.
The case against Bell was complicated by a lack of definitive medical standards involving the treatment of pain patients, state officials said. As a result, investigators focused on evidence that she failed to properly monitor her patients or document their care.
Steers has not been the subject of any disciplinary charges by the state. However, Health Department officials said last week that some investigations of Bell and Steers remain open.
Ten days after Bell’s charges were settled, a Health Department lawyer wrote an email in which he expressed misgivings. “In retrospect,” he wrote to colleagues, he was “afraid” the allegations against Bell had been handled “too narrowly.”
Mark McDougal, the lead Portland attorney for the families suing the clinic, said of the state’s handling of the charges: “I think it’s nothing more than sheer incompetence.”
This year, Bell and Pecora filed for bankruptcy, saying they were more than $200,000 in the hole and facing foreclosure on their home.
After Payette closed, Bell and Steers both remained in the field of pain management. Steers went to work for a medical-marijuana authorization clinic. Bell and Pecora opened a new clinic in Vancouver that, according to its website, offers a pain-relief therapy using injections of blood platelets mixed with a numbing agent.
Michael J. Berens: 206-464-2288 or firstname.lastname@example.org;
Ken Armstrong: 206-464-3730 or email@example.com