National safety board calls out the “diffusion of responsibility” by four rail agencies that didn’t challenge an unsafe curve design of the track near DuPont where the derailment occurred.

Share story

The engineer in last December’s Amtrak Cascades derailment worried about the dangerous curve at DuPont, received a phone call from a foreman to remind him of the hazard, and tried in vain to see a speed-limit sign.

Robert Sumwalt, chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), revealed those details Tuesday, during an investigative hearing in Washington, D.C.

Traffic Lab is a Seattle Times project that digs into the region’s thorny transportation issues, spotlights promising approaches to easing gridlock, and helps readers find the best ways to get around. It is funded with the help of community sponsors Alaska Airlines, CenturyLink, Kemper Development Co., NHL Seattle, PEMCO Mutual Insurance Company and Seattle Children’s hospital. Seattle Times editors and reporters operate independently of our funders and maintain editorial control over Traffic Lab content.

Learn more about Traffic Lab » | Follow us on Twitter »

The engineer, identified in records as Steve Brown, 55, had made two northbound and one southbound training runs in the new corridor between Lakewood and Nisqually, before the Dec. 18 derailment that killed three people and injured 62 others. He also passed a written exam and took seven to 10 observational rides.

The NTSB waited four weeks to interview the injured engineer. Brown told investigators about a last-minute change in locomotives, and he described a call from a railroad foreman shortly before leaving Seattle, according to the NTSB interview transcript posted online.

“He was concerned that he or another road foreman wouldn’t be with me on the trip. And we talked about some of the physical characteristics, including the curve, in that call,” he said.

Investigators asked Brown if he remembered what he said about the curve or what he was saying.

“Just we all hated that curve,” the engineer recalled. “Everybody hated that curve. Everybody was concerned about the curve.”

The train, making its first-ever passenger trip on a renovated Tacoma-Nisqually route, was going southbound at 80 mph when it reached a 30 mph curve and derailed. Some railcars landed on Interstate 5, beneath a gray train overpass at DuPont.

NTSB members mentioned Brown was trying to look for a white sign. They speculated his peripheral vision was hindered within the unfamiliar locomotive. The sky was dark and rainy.

A small amber, diagonal sign, right of the rails, says “P 30” some two miles before the curve, to warn that a 30 mph zone lies ahead. Event-recorder data say emergency brakes weren’t applied.

Michael DeCataldo, vice president of Amtrak operations, said that under new safety reforms, engineers must complete at least four practice trips, depending on difficulty, to qualify in new territory.

He admitted that as many as seven people rode in the front cab last year during night practice trips, exceeding Amtrak standards, in the Lakewood-Nisqually area.

NTSB board member Bella Dinh-Zarr asked if Washington state considered waiting until positive train control systems are ready, as written in the corridor plan, to automatically slow an over-speeding train.

“We did not,” said Ron Pate, rail director at Washington State Department of Transportation. Over two decades, some 14 million passengers have ridden Cascades trains, operating under longstanding dispatch and safety methods, Pate said.

Federal Railroad Administration officials said the corridor met regulations, because Congress had stretched its 2015 deadline for the positive train control system until December 2018.

Nonetheless, board member Earl Weener questioned why someone didn’t challenge the decision to run trains that must decelerate 50 mph for the curve — especially after a 2015 curve derailment that killed eight people in Philadelphia.

“A lot of people had the chance, so nobody stood up to say, that is not a good design?” asked Weener, an aerospace engineer. “So this is an issue of diffusion of responsibility.”

Cascades trains are owned by the state, operated by Amtrak, on tracks owned by Sound Transit in the Tacoma to DuPont corridor, through BNSF Railway’s dispatch territory, under Federal Railroad Administration regulation.

The $181 million Tacoma-Lakewood-Nisqually corridor should save 10 minutes and make schedules more reliable for Seattle-to-Portland trains, which take a scenic but slow waterfront path through Tacoma Narrows, mixed with freight trains.

Other highlights from Tuesday’s hearing:

• Before issuing a final report, the NTSB plans to obtain medical records, to study whether passenger injuries match what the Federal Railroad Administration research predicts for the lightweight Talgo railcars. They were built around 1998 but “grandfathered” for modern use, after retrofits to strengthen the ends and connections.

• The board mentioned the lack of “cab signals,” that trigger an alarm if a speeding train passes trackside detectors. Sound Transit’s commuter-rail manager, Martin Young, replied they’ve not been considered for Sounder trains, and cab signals for Cascades would be up to Amtrak.

• Amtrak is still testing its positive train control system in Western Washington. Meanwhile, Sounder’s new system is now 90 percent reliable, technical staff reported two weeks ago. That’s improved from 56 percent last winter, when sporadic lost connections halted trains midtrip. Amtrak Cascades trips via DuPont could return by December. Trains would still need special operating rules, for occasions the positive train control system doesn’t work.