Durkan caught flak for her police-chief selection process and joined the City Council in a U-turn on the city's controversial head tax. More recently, the council adopted the mayor's police contract and her first budget, and voters approved a new education levy.

Share story

When Seattle residents first learned that Mayor Jenny Durkan wouldn’t consider Carmen Best for the job of police chief, at a news conference that drew intense blowback from community groups, Durkan was absent, initially leaving others to take the heat.

This month, as the City Council weighed a police-union contract opposed by many of the same groups, she was everywhere, rallying for the contract with Best at her side.

Durkan has struggled through some storms in her first year as mayor, scrambling to appoint Best with a rejiggered selection process and working to engineer the repeal of a controversial head tax on large businesses less than a month after signing the measure.

But there are signs the former U.S. attorney, who took office last Nov. 28, is building political momentum. In the past month, the council passed her police contract and her first budget, and voters approved her massive education levy, which will grow Seattle’s subsidized-preschool program.

“She’s getting her sea legs and is moving the way she needs to do” while contending with a knotty council and a hostile Trump administration, former Mayor Norm Rice said. “I don’t envy her challenges.”

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, who is coming up on a year in office, visited a business during a neighborhood tour in West Seattle, Monday, Nov. 12, 2018. Chief of Police Carmen Best, right, accompanied the mayor. (Ken Lambert / The Seattle Times)

Opinions differ on whether an empowered Durkan will take the city in the right direction, with some critics accusing her of doing too little to address gentrification and others pressing her to get tougher on crime and unauthorized camping.

The pact she brokered by halving the size of the head tax pleased almost no one: Activists slammed her for appeasing Amazon and mega-rich Jeff Bezos while business leaders and frustrated residents pushed to kill the measure. The tax would have allowed Seattle to build more low-income housing and provide more homeless services.

“It just seemed like she was supporting wealthier folks,” said Yin Yu, an anti-gentrification organizer with the Chinatown International District Coalition.

“She’s not treating displacement like a state of emergency. We’re going to be looking like Belltown soon, with bourgie Asian food not cooked by the people with that heritage.”

Several Seattle departments still lack permanent directors, the First Avenue streetcar line remains in limbo and homelessness is a continuing problem, with Durkan set to miss by far a key campaign vow — 1,000 tiny houses in her first year.

The Seattle Human Rights Commission last week called on the administration to stop evicting people from unauthorized homeless camps.

Polling during the head-tax debate apparently put Durkan well ahead of the council in favorability, though, and her term has brought stability to a city rocked by Ed Murray’s sexual-abuse scandal.

The mayor can point to accomplishments, including a number of promises met. Her administration has added hundreds of shelter beds, cut Seattle City Light’s customer-complaint backlog and put transit passes in the hands of every public high school student. A new unit will investigate city-employee allegations of workplace discrimination and harassment.

“We’ve probably done more to reform government internally in a year than has happened in Seattle in a very long time,” Durkan said.


In her early months, the mayor hung back from the head-tax debate. After Amazon threatened to stop growing in Seattle, Durkan negotiated with the council to pass a smaller tax, citing the deal as proof “we can find common ground.”

The compromise collapsed, however, as Amazon and other companies bankrolled a referendum effort to nix the measure. They were bolstered by voters with concerns about City Hall spending.

Reversing the tax would have been awkward enough, but Durkan and council members also courted controversy by conferring behind closed doors to rush the action.

Councilmember Teresa Mosqueda, who voted against the repeal urged by the mayor, said Seattle giving up nearly $50 million in annual revenue was a missed opportunity. “We cannot warehouse people in shelters forever,” she said. “We have to have more revenue to invest in housing.” Durkan said canceling the tax saved the city from a divisive ballot battle.

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, who is coming up on a year in office, visited Cupcake Royale and talked to constituents during a neighborhood tour in West Seattle, Monday, Nov. 12, 2018. (Ken Lambert / The Seattle Times)

A second storm brewed in May when Durkan advisers trimmed police-chief finalists recommended by her community search committee, omitting Best. The move drew fire both from rank-and-file cops and police-reform activists.

As with the head tax, the blowback appeared to catch the mayor off guard, and as with the tax, the mayor swerved, bouncing Best back to the top of the list.

Though she risked being branded a backpedaler, Durkan said the decisions were right because she acted on what constituents were telling her. To date, the mayor has taken part in more than 200 community events, meetings and walking tours, her office said.

“There’s nothing I’m not proud of what the city and our team has done,” she said. “I think our greatest accomplishment … is that we are listening to communities.”

Erin Goodman, Sodo Business Improvement Area executive director, was happy with the attention her neighborhood received early this year, applauding a pilot program to clear unauthorized vehicle camps.

Goodman said she saw a “hard drop” in engagement as the mayor grappled with the head tax and chief selection. “I think she walled herself off,” Goodman said, who thinks the administration is now revving up again.

Political wins

Three marquee wins for Durkan in November should give her a boost.

The education levy she proposed passed with nearly 70 percent of the vote, setting the stage for more than $600 million in spending on K-12 and preschool programs while also paying for the free community college she promised as a candidate.

Durkan can’t claim all credit, but the levy’s backers stamped her face on their campaign mailers and she described the victory as her top moment.

“To have it pass with voters by that margin just affirms how great Seattle is,” the mayor said, adding, “Getting those kids at preschool ready to learn, really working to close the opportunity gap and then getting the two years free college” will help youth snag well-paying jobs later on.

Durkan prevailed again when the council almost unanimously approved her police-union contract. The Community Police Commission, 24 community groups and the Seattle King County NAACP opposed the deal, saying it would water down reforms meant to stamp out police brutality and misconduct.

But Councilmember Lisa Herbold provided a key vote the day after Durkan stumped with Best in Herbold’s district. In a West Seattle Junction cafe, locals applauded when the mayor told them the contract would mean raises for cops.

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, who is coming up on a year in office, spoke to Dave Montoure, co-owner of restaurant West 5, during a neighborhood tour in West Seattle, Monday, Nov. 12, 2018. Montoure asked for more policing. (Ken Lambert / The Seattle Times)

“She’s doing the right things,” bar owner Dave Montoure said, praising Durkan for showing more spending restraint in her budget than past mayors while urging her to hire more police officers to address public drug use and street crime.

Junction businesses have been broken into and robbed, and Montoure has had to install new locks at his bar to stop people from shooting up in the restrooms, he said, adding, “I wish she would kick the council hard in the butt and tell them to heel.”

Last week, the council adopted the mayor’s 2019 budget with only minor changes rather than supporting Councilmember Kshama Sawant in another bid to raise taxes.

Councilmember Rob Johnson described Durkan as a “back to basics” mayor. He said her measured and methodical approach is needed as Seattle tries to catch up with growth.

This week, Durkan will highlight other deeds, including 681,000 pounds of trash collected from unauthorized homeless camps in the past year and an agreement to renovate KeyArena without public money.

With City Attorney Pete Holmes, the mayor persuaded the Seattle Municipal Court to vacate marijuana convictions from before legalization and, with the council, she signed a law requiring gun owners to keep their firearms locked up at home. Fulfilling a campaign promise to immigrant and labor advocates, she advanced legislation extending additional rights to domestic workers.

Marilyn Strickland, Seattle Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce president, gave the mayor a “solid B” grade.

“I think most people want to see a leader succeed and demonstrate competence, and I think she’s doing that,” she said.

Future questions

Not everyone is satisfied. Like Yu, who said Durkan must do more to help nonprofits outbid luxury hotel and housing developers, local NAACP President Gerald Hankerson said the mayor is allowing people of color to continue to be pushed out of the city by high costs.

Though Seattle is investing $100 million this year in low-income housing, “I see no concrete plan or strategy to make sure people can stay,” Hankerson said. “She hasn’t done enough for the African-American community.”

Southeast Seattle Education Coalition’s Erin Okuno applauded the education levy’s passage but cringed when Durkan initially cut elementary-school programs from her plan. The reductions were mostly restored by the council.

In her neighborhood, many voters still are taking cues from 2017 candidate Nikkita Oliver, Okuno said. “I think her voice resonates more,” she said.

The mayor is trying to assist community organizations, she said, citing $5 million per year in Airbnb tax revenue earmarked for their anti-gentrification projects. “My regret is that we can’t do that more quickly,” she said.

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, who is coming up on a year in office, visited businesses and talked to constituents during a neighborhood tour in West Seattle, Monday, Nov. 12, 2018. Chief of Police Carmen Best, right, accompanied the mayor. (Ken Lambert / The Seattle Times)

On homelessness, the Durkan administration has boosted shelter beds with enhanced services from 668 last year to 1,411, her office said, while adding fewer than 100 tiny houses, rather than 1,000.

Durkan has come to view enhanced beds and system improvements as most important, she said. The city moved 35 percent more households to permanent housing in the first half of 2018 than in the first half of 2017, her office said. It’s not yet clear whether the administration will meet its goal of housing 7,400 people by 2019.

The 1,000-tiny house target isn’t “what people care about,” the mayor said. “You’ve got to focus not on numbers. You’ve got to focus on results.”

Sarah Stewart said she voted for Durkan because she thought the mayor would make strides on homelessness. The 49-year-old from north Seattle, who has lived in her car and with friends since March, has seen little progress.

“I’ve been very disappointed,” she said. “I’ve been bouncing around everywhere because it’s very difficult to get housing.”

The mayor appears to draw energy from neighborhood outings. On a recent Saturday, she visited a youth group in South Park, then held a town hall on Queen Anne.

Durkan has yet to name a permanent transportation director, and traffic snarled in January by the Alaskan Way Viaduct shutdown could curb her momentum. But the mayor is feeling confident.

Even as she issued a warning to the audience — “It’s going to be bad,” she said, eliciting nervous laughter — and described the city’s preparations, Durkan sounded somehow upbeat.