Prosecutors have filed a first-degree murder charge against the man arrested in connection with the slaying and dismemberment of a Renton mother of three.

Share story

Prosecutors have filed a first-degree murder charge against the man arrested in connection with the slaying and dismemberment of Renton mother Ingrid Lyne.

John Robert Charlton, 37, has been held in lieu of $2 million bail following his arrest Monday, three days after Lyne disappeared after a date and two days after her head and other body parts were found in a Central District recycling bin.

Charlton was also charged Wednesday with stealing Lyne’s car.

“The tragic murder of Ingrid Lyne has left a family and community in a spiral of grief and anguish,” King County Prosecuting Attorney Dan Satterberg said in a statement. “We may never understand why she was killed.”

If convicted as charged, Charlton could face a sentence of 21 to nearly 28 years in prison.

He is scheduled to be arraigned April 27.

During a brief bail hearing Tuesday, Charlton’s public defender, Gordon Hill, argued there was no forensic evidence or other ties linking Charlton to Lyne’s death. A judge rejected those arguments and ordered him held.

The charges filed Wednesday in King County Superior Court shed little new light on the circumstances of Lyne’s death and do not offer a motive in her killing.

Court documents do, however, provide new details about Charlton, who spoke briefly with detectives after his arrest. He later asked for an attorney and invoked his right to avoid self-incrimination, according to the court documents.

Charlton told detectives he was homeless, had a drinking problem and was “not a normal person,” according to the charging documents.

He said he and Lyne, 40, a registered nurse at Swedish Medical Center, had met online and had been dating about a month, the charges said. Charlton said they went to the Mariners game Friday and then to a bar, where he got drunk, then back to Lyne’s home in the Renton Highlands.

Evidence later found by police indicate that is where Lyne was likely killed and dismembered in the bathtub. Detectives found a saw in the bathroom and blood and flesh in the drains during a search Monday night, the court documents say.

Charlton said he awoke Saturday on a sidewalk in downtown Seattle, which is where detectives later found Lyne’s 2015 Toyota Highlander.

Saturday afternoon, as Lyne’s family and friends frantically searched for her, a resident near 21st Avenue and East Pine Street found three trash bags in his recently emptied recycle bin. He dumped them onto the grass, was able to identify a human foot and called 911.

The King County Medical Examiner’s Office on Wednesday confirmed the remains were those of Lyne. The medical examiner said Lyne died as the result of homicidal violence but has not determined the day of her death.

Court documents say Charlton and Lyne had planned to attend a Mariners game Friday night at Safeco Field. However, he told detectives that he became so intoxicated that he couldn’t recall how he got to her house after the game, “or what transpired when they got there.”

Lyne wasn’t at her Renton home Saturday morning when her ex-husband, Phil Lyne, stopped to drop off the couple’s three daughters, ages 12, 10 and 7.

After he summoned Lyne’s mother, Jorga Bass, they went inside and found the missing woman’s wallet, cellphone and other personal items, the documents say. Bass called police.

Bass and Lyne shared a phone account, and Bass noted repeated calls to and from a phone number with a Montana area code later traced to Charlton.

On Saturday, Bass texted the number and pleaded for information about Lyne, the documents say.

She received the response: “My name is John, I thought she was with her kids today?”

Bass asked when he had seen her last and explained that Lyne’s purse and cellphone were at the home. “Please respond,” she wrote. “I’ve called 911.”

Charlton texted back, “911? What’s going on? We went to the Mariner’s game last night but we didn’t stay the night together because she has her kids today …”

Bass texted Charlton that Lyne was missing, the documents say.

“A police officer needs to speak to you as you may be the last person who saw her,” Bass wrote.

Charlton did not respond, according to the documents.

By Sunday, dozens of panicked friends and family took to social media and began calling police and the media about Lyne’s disappearance, identifying Charlton as her date.

During a search of Lyne’s home, homicide detectives found bits of flesh and a 15-inch pruning saw in a bathroom, documents say. They also found a box of kitchen trash bags that “appear identical in color and size” to the bags containing the body parts.

Swedish Medical Center issued a statement Wednesday saying Lyne’s death “has been incredibly tragic and shocking for all of us. Our hearts are heavy as this news brings a feeling of profound loss for the Swedish family and all who knew and loved Ingrid.”