Seattle should look to England for examples of thriving downtown retail districts with no cars.

Share story

This spring I spent more than a month in the English cities of Nottingham, Manchester and London; and in Cardiff, Wales.

In Nottingham, a city of 321,000, I was delighted to find an enormous vehicle-free commercial shopping district. I immediately thought of Seattle, where, despite years of periodic discussion, our business, civic and elected officials have yet to make Pike Place vehicle-free, a distance of only several blocks between Pike and Virginia streets.

Pike Place Market offers a solid mix of small mom-and-pop shops, a hotel, community health clinic, taverns, restaurants, buskers, vendors, fishmongers, book and music sellers and apartments.

‘My take’

Got something to say about a topic in the news? We’re looking for personal essays with strong opinions. Send your submission of no more than 500 words to with the subject line “My Take.”

The hordes of tourists and intrepid locals who frequent the stalls and shops also mustdodge traffic creeping down Pike Place. Why? It doesn’t make sense.

Just imagine if Seattle had a commercially thriving, U.K.- style, vehicle-free shopping district through the market. Or think bigger and imagine a retail district with no cars between First and Fifth avenues and University and Virginia streets. Far-fetched? It works in Nottingham and Cardiff — Manchester too — so why not Seattle?

The vehicle-free district in Nottingham was packed with shoppers and pedestrians, day and evening. I was struck by how many people were out and about, walking and enjoying the neighborhood without fear of cars.

Exceptions are made for delivery trucks; street-cleaning vehicles; city services (police, fire, emergency), and to allow people to pick up or drop off people with disabilities.

Cardiff, with 341,000 residents, has a comparably large shopping and business district. With residential flats above shops, the vehicle-free district was thriving, just like Nottingham. Businesses include everything from mom-and-pop stores, to eateries, national chains and U.S.-based retailers. And, of course, Starbucks.

The vehicle-free districts in Nottingham and Cardiff also have city-block-sized shopping-center buildings within their retail districts. Imagine a Northgate or Southcenter plunked into Seattle’s retail core and packed with thousands of shoppers every day, rain or shine.

While there are periodic news reports that Britain lags economically, I had no idea just how popular their vehicular-free districts appear. It was exhilarating and invigorating.

Why can’t Seattle start by making Pike Place shopping, sightseeing and browsing a truly enjoyable experience for locals and visitors?

What are our city leaders waiting for?