PLATTSBURGH, N.Y. (AP) — A prison worker who was “in over her head” with two inmates convicted of murder tearfully pleaded guilty Tuesday to helping them escape as new details emerged of her relationship with the men that included performing a sex act and sending naked photos.
Joyce Mitchell, an instructor in the tailor shop at the Clinton Correctional Facility in upstate New York, wore shackles and prison stripes as she entered the pleas in a barely audible voice.
Afterward, her lawyer, Stephen Johnston, said she realizes she made a “horrible mistake” by getting involved with Richard Matt and David Sweat, who staged an elaborate escape from the maximum-security prison on June 6.
“She got in over her head into something that she never should have started. But she did, and she’s paying the price now,” Johnston told reporters outside court. “I think that to a certain extent, Matt got her to feeling good about herself, better than she had for a period of time, and she was swept off her feet a bit. … And then when she realized who she was dealing with, everything changed.”
Most Read Nation & World Stories
- You should probably replace some of your fabric face masks
- Honestie Hodges, whose mistreatment by police led to changes, dies of COVID. She was 14.
- Trump pardons Flynn despite guilty plea in Russia probe
- A Trump-boosting sheriff earned White House visits. Now she's charged with theft.
- Secret Hasidic wedding in Brooklyn draws thousands of guests, $15K fine
Matt was shot and killed by searchers June 26, about 30 miles west of the prison. Sweat was captured near the Canadian border two days later and sent to another prison.
Mitchell, 51, faces a sentence of 2 1/3 to seven years in prison under terms of a plea deal with prosecutors. Sentencing is set for Sept. 28. Johnston said his client will not be able to post the bail of $100,000 cash or $200,000 bond.
In documents first obtained by NBC News, Mitchell told investigators she believed she helped the two inmates escape because she “was caught up in the fantasy.”
“I enjoyed the attention, the feeling both of them gave me and the thought of a different life,” Mitchell said in a statement.
“Matt told me they were getting out and we were all going to be together,” Mitchell said after Matt confided in the escape plan.
In April, Mitchell said she was alone with Matt in the tailor shop when he grabbed her and kissed her.
“It startled me. He kissed me with an open mouth kiss. I didn’t say anything because I was scared for my husband, who also works for the facility,” Mitchell said.
In May, Matt asked her to perform oral sex and she so did out of fear, Mitchell said. On other occasions, she said, Matt would come to her desk wearing a large coat in which he’d cut a hole so that Mitchell could fondle him.
She also said she took naked photos of her breasts and genitals and gave them to Matt to give to Sweat.
District Attorney Andrew Wylie said separate cases against Sweat and a Gene Palmer, a guard who investigators accuse of unwittingly helping the two inmates, are expected to go before a grand jury next month.
“At this time, there are no other individuals who have been identified through the investigation as being involved directly or indirectly” with the escape, Wylie said.
Prosecutors say Mitchell provided hacksaw blades, chisels, a punch tool and a screwdriver to Matt on May 1. Authorities say she became close with the pair and agreed to be their getaway driver. But she backed out at the last moment, forcing the two to flee on foot after they emerged from a manhole near the prison.
Investigators also said Mitchell had discussed killing her husband, Lyle Mitchell, as part of the plot.
Lyle Mitchell was in court Tuesday and declined to speak with an Associated Press reporter.
Wylie said a grand jury could have considered other counts against Joyce Mitchell, including conspiracy to commit murder and sexual-related charges based on allegations involving the inmates. But he said he accepted pleas on two clearly provable charges — first-degree promoting prison contraband, a felony, and fourth-degree criminal facilitation, a misdemeanor— “in the interest of justice.”
The deal requires Mitchell to cooperate with a probe by the state inspector general.
Authorities said Joyce Mitchell smuggled the tools into the prison by hiding them in frozen meat she placed in a refrigerator in the tailor shop. They said Palmer then took the meat to Sweat and Matt, who were housed in a section where inmates are allowed to cook their meals.
Authorities do not believe Palmer knew of the escape plan. He was released on bail after being arrested on charges including promoting prison contraband.
Mitchell, who was arrested June 12, resigned from her job but remains eligible for a pension, according to corrections officials and the state comptroller’s office.
Matt and Sweat cut through their adjoining cell walls over months, climbed down catwalks to tunnels and broke through a brick wall. They then cut into a steam pipe and cut a chain holding a manhole cover outside the prison to get away, authorities said.