VATICAN CITY (AP) — Pope Francis on Monday urged the world’s Catholic bishops to put aside personal prejudices and have the courage and humility to be guided by the “surprises” of God, as he opened a meeting on family issues marked by sharp divisions between conservatives and progressives.
Francis told some 270 cardinals, bishops and priests that the three-week synod isn’t a parliament where negotiations, plea bargains or compromises take place. Rather, he said, it’s a sacred, protected space where God shows the way for the good of the church.
The bishops are debating how the church can better care for Catholic families at a time when marriage rates are falling, divorce is common and civil unions are on the rise. The main sticking points include how the church should welcome gays and divorced and civilly remarried Catholics.
Conservatives have been insisting that the gathering strongly reassert church doctrine on homosexuality and the indissolubility of marriage. Progressives are seeking a more merciful approach to a host of family problems, including whether civilly remarried Catholics can receive the sacraments.
Most Read Nation & World Stories
- How do you live to be 100? Good genes, getting outside and friends
- Why nonalcoholic beer beats regular beer after exercise
- New study finds 6 ways to slow memory decline and lower dementia risk
- Latest Santos chaos: 'Hiring' treasurer who turned down job
- Earth’s inner core paused, then reversed its spin. This is fine
Despite Francis’ call for a free and open debate, Hungarian Cardinal Peter Erdo, a key synod organizer who delivered the introductory remarks, made clear that there wasn’t much to discuss on the divorce-remarriage issue since church teaching is clear forbidding the sacraments for these Catholics.
The ringleader of the progressive camp, German Cardinal Reinhard Marx, seemed to acknowledge that the synod wouldn’t make any major move, though the German church has essentially gone its own way by proposing case-by-case pastoral care for civilly remarried Catholics.
“The important thing is that nobody goes below the pope’s words,” in proposing less than what the pope has, Marx told reporters Monday. He said while he didn’t expect any new laws, he did expect “concrete impulses” to emerge and that regardless: “At the end, the pope will do what he wants to do.”
In his opening welcome Monday, Francis repeated a phrase he used in his homily a day earlier, that the church’s law cannot become an impediment to its mission of mercy. He called for the bishops to show apostolic courage, evangelical humility and faithful prayer over the next three weeks.
The run-up to the synod has been particularly contentious: Conservatives have been mounting a campaign to insist that Catholic doctrine be strongly reasserted, particularly on the indissolubility of marriage and impossibility of civilly remarried Catholics receiving Communion without an annulment. Progressives have been plotting their own strategy to try to find wiggle room in pastoral practice.
Cardinal Andre Vingt-Trois, the archbishop of Paris, cautioned that anyone expecting changes to doctrine, or even general recommendations to the pope to emerge from the synod would be sorely disappointed. But he suggested that the issue on Communion for the civilly remarried comes down to one of individual conscience.
“If there’s a path to be opened, it’s one that takes into consideration a personal commitment, a personal freedom,” he said.
Catholics who divorce and want to remarry in the church must first obtain an annulment, a ruling from a church tribunal that their first marriage was invalid. Otherwise, those who remarry in civil ceremonies are considered to be committing adultery and cannot receive Communion, a condition that has led generations of Catholics to feel shunned by their church.
Francis has upheld church teaching on marriage but has sought a more merciful approach, insisting that these remarried Catholics be fully part of the life of the church. Progressive prelates led by German Cardinal Walter Kasper have called for a process by which a bishop could accompany these remarried Catholics on a path of penance that, over time and on a case-by-case basis, could lead to them receiving the sacraments.
In a bid to take some of the divisiveness out of the debate, Francis passed a law over the summer making it easier for Catholics to get an annulment — a change conservatives have criticized as tantamount to “Catholic divorce.”
Vingt-Trois praised the new annulment process as a “precious” initiative that should help bishops “better put in place paths of mercy.”
But Erdo, in a keynote speech addressing the main themes for the synod, made clear that Communion for civilly remarried Catholics is effectively impossible unless they abstain from sex — as the church’s teaching currently states.
Erdo said his remarks were informed by responses from bishops around the world who had gotten in touch even after the Vatican drafted the working paper for the meeting, suggesting a hardening of positions against any change in pastoral practice.
That said, he allowed for developments.
“The synod begins today,” he said. “It’s not like we have answers to all the questions.
AP writer Daniela Petroff contributed to this report.
Follow Nicole Winfield at www.twitter.com/nwinfield