A New York City council member has introduced a bill requiring most office high-rises to turn off the lights at night as a way to cut energy costs and help migratory birds.
NEW YORK — Bright lights, big city?
Not so much, if a New York City council member gets his way.
He’s introduced a bill requiring most office high-rises to turn off the lights at night as a way to cut energy costs and help migratory birds. And it might even give New Yorkers a chance to see some stars other than the celebrities walking down the street.
“We need to be doing everything we can to conserve energy,” said Councilman Donovan Richards Jr. “This is a common-sense measure. It’s not going to cost anybody a lot of money.”
Most Read Nation & World Stories
- At Alaska's most popular national park, climate change threatens the only road in and out
- Sports on TV & radio: Local listings for Seattle games and events
- Could this new version of an old grain help fight climate change and feed the world?
- Woman raped on train as bystanders did nothing, police say
- Moderna vs. Pfizer: Both knockouts, but one seems to have the edge
Seventy-one percent of New Yorkers like the idea, according to a Quinnipiac University poll released Thursday of 969 registered city voters. But the bill, one of the first in the city focusing on what supporters call “light pollution,” is causing concern among some residents who worry that dimming the lights could make the city less safe and dampen its signature sparkle.
For Joyetta McCullen, who lives in Brooklyn, the lights are part of what makes her city special, even though she has often wondered why buildings keep all their lights on at night when there’s no one working.
“I’m 25, lived in New York all my life, that’s all I saw,” she said, “lights and noise.”
Richards’ proposal is aimed at commercial buildings at least 20 stories high, and requires them to turn off the lights after midnight if no one is inside. On a recent dusk, whole floors could be seen lit up in high-rise buildings in midtown Manhattan, even long after most workers had left for the day.
It would exempt landmarks such as the Empire State Building and the Chrysler Building, as well as the city’s brightest nighttime tourist draw, Times Square.
Richards said he was inspired in part by a trip to Paris last year. The City of Light has had office and shop buildings turning off their lights at night for the past couple of years. And if Paris can do it, he said, New York City can, too.
“We should be the world leader for conservation,” he said.
At a hearing on the measure last month, critics raised issues of safety, and whether the law would just add more onerous regulations for building owners and the potential for fines.
The Daily News of New York was even stronger in an editorial headlined: “We’ll not go gentle: Keep New York City’s nighttime skyline bright and beautiful.”
It went on to say Richards “means well, much as those who would have us ration the paint and canvas wasted in the production of museum masterpieces might mean well” but that turning off the lights would “cast a permanent pall over one of America’s most beautiful sights.”
Hardly, said Scott Kardel, managing director of the Tucson, Ariz.-based International Dark-Sky Association, which advocates against light pollution.
“No one’s talking about plunging people into darkness and chaos like you get when there’s a major disaster,” Kardel said. “It’s really just dialing it back when there’s an opportunity to do that. It’s not going to change significantly the ambience at street level.”
Bird lovers say lowering the light level would also help migrating species, many of which fly through the night and can become confused and disoriented by bright city lights.
“It would be a wonderful message from New York City to do this,” said Susan Elbin, director of conservation and science for New York City Audubon.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced last month that state buildings would turn off nonessential lights from 11 p.m. to dawn through the spring and fall, peak bird-migration times.