Former Washington Post journalist Carol Krucoff shares her experience with “watchful waiting,” or “active surveillance” — deciding to monitor a brain tumor rather than undergo removal or treatment right away. It taught her to live fully in the moment.
Watching my little brain tumor grow slowly over the past 10 years has been an extraordinary exercise in courage, patience, gratitude and faith.
I learned about my tumor by accident in 2003, around my 50th birthday, when I’d had an MRI scan after collapsing from drinking too much water during a marathon.
Fortunately, my tumor is a benign and generally slow-growing type called an acoustic neuroma. Located inside my skull on the nerve responsible for hearing and balance, it measured just 3 millimeters — about the size of a sesame seed — when discovered. Although I had no symptoms, an expert I consulted recommended two possible treatments: surgery to remove it or radiation to stop its growth. While this tumor wouldn’t metastasize, its growth could impair my facial nerves, balance and hearing, or even threaten crucial brain function. She advised acting early, when the tumor was small. Instead, I decided on a course of action known as “watch and wait.”
Also called “expectant management,” “active surveillance” and “watchful waiting,” this involves closely monitoring an ailment but withholding treatment unless symptoms appear or progress. Often used with slow-growing or precancerous lesions and with conditions where treatment risks may outweigh benefits, this strategy does not mean doing nothing. It involves regular checkups. And it requires a tolerance for uncertainty, the willingness to live with something that could be a ticking time bomb or a harmless growth.
Most Read Stories
- Seattle’s income tax on the wealthy is illegal, judge rules
- Analysis: Five reasons the Seahawks waived Dwight Freeney WATCH
- Retired Alabama cop on Roy Moore: ‘We were also told to ... make sure that he didn’t hang around the cheerleaders’
- Jobs that pay without a B.A.: the most lucrative fields in Washington state
- A Washington syrah was named second best wine in the world
Over a decade of watchful waiting, I’ve had 10 MRIs. Each of these scans was followed by a hearing test and a meeting with my doctor. I’m grateful to have health insurance, which means I paid $160 in coinsurance for the $3,579 MRI that I received recently and $50 for a $960 hearing test/doctor’s appointment.
The emotional cost, however, is harder to calculate.
When first diagnosed, I immediately went on the Internet and learned that most acoustic neuromas are slow-growing — but others expand rapidly. Anytime I felt dizzy or had trouble hearing, I worried. I joined a support group and met a woman whose surgery to remove an asymptomatic 2-millimeter tumor had left her with crippling headaches and facial pain. I logged on to the discussion forum on the Acoustic Neuroma Association’s website and read horror stories of botched treatments as well as wonderful examples of excellent results. After several months of almost daily trips to the forum, I became overwhelmed by the anxiety these posts aroused and signed off.
I tried to remain calm over the years as I watched my tumor’s creeping growth, at a rate of about 1 millimeter — the size of a grain of sugar — a year.
Navigating an emotional tightrope between responsible vigilance and anxious obsession, I gratefully clung to the fact that I had no symptoms. My hearing and balance seemed unaffected. My yoga practice proved extremely helpful, since a central teaching is finding equilibrium — that steady place between effort and surrender — which is the key to watchful waiting.
By 2006, about three years after it was discovered, my tumor had grown to 6 millimeters — about the size of a pea. At my doctor’s urging, I met with a radiation oncologist, who recommended that I undergo treatment.
But since I was still asymptomatic and the tumor was still small, I chose to continue watchful waiting. I’d read that some tumors stop growing on their own, and I hoped this would be the case with mine.
In April 2013, based on an article I had written about the accidental discovery of my tumor, I was asked to testify before the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues at a meeting devoted to the ethical implications of incidental findings. Representing the patient’s perspective, I told the panel: “As a health journalist I’d always thought there was great benefit in early detection. However, my experience has made me question the wisdom of learning about an abnormality if all it offers is anxiety — as well as potential harm from treatments for something that might never affect my health.”
Yet when a panel member asked me, “Do you really wish that you simply had never been told?” I had to admit: “Definitely no. If (the doctors) know, I want to know. I wouldn’t want to be shielded for my own protection. That’s my decision; this is my brain.”
Ironically, four months after my testimony, I had my scheduled MRI and hearing tests and learned that my tumor now measured 1.2 centimeters — about the size of a small walnut.
While I still had no symptoms, tests of my vestibular function — the sensory system that contributes to balance — on the affected side were abnormal even though I had not experienced balance problems. Continued growth would now mean a strong likelihood of negative effects on my hearing and facial nerves. It was time to take action.
I spent six weeks visiting brain surgeons and radiation oncologists, spoke with patients who had chosen each approach, then made a decision to have what is known as gamma knife radio surgery.
In my decade of waiting, there had been significant advances in this minimally invasive treatment option, which uses imaging to direct gamma radiation very precisely to a target point.
In February 2014, I had the morninglong outpatient procedure. By the following week I felt fine, and I was back to teaching yoga.
Tests done six months and then one year later showed that my hearing and the tumor were stable. Thankfully, I have felt no ill effects from the procedure, although I have been told that effects of radiation may emerge years later.So I will be watching and waiting for some time. And I am not alone.
The boom in life expectancy — from about 47 years in 1900 to about 78 in 2012 — has resulted in an unprecedented “silver tsunami” of older adults, and technological advances mean an increased likelihood of finding some abnormality during those extra decades of life. While humans have always been aware of our mortality, we have never been able to so clearly see the approaching train that may take us out.
For me, this unsettling knowledge presents a spiritual opportunity. Like the ancient yogis who were taught to imagine death sitting on their shoulder, I have learned that having a heightened awareness of impermanence can serve to make the present moment that much sweeter.
And in my case, watchful waiting involves more than my little brain tumor. As with the old joke “What do you always look for but hope never to find?” (Answer: a run in your stocking), I’m continually monitoring a variety of conditions.
I have regular echocardiograms to check my prosthetic heart valve. I have twice-yearly examinations by a retina specialist for a potentially precancerous “eye freckle” called a choroidal nevus. A dermatologist checks multiple moles on my skin.
That said, I’m grateful to feel quite well, thank you. I walk my dog several miles every morning, practice and teach yoga.
My friends marvel at how such a healthy person can have such a long list of medical problems, and they often compliment me on my bravery. The truth is, I’ve been terrified facing brain radiation, open-heart surgery and other challenges, and I have had some dark moments. But I’m grateful to have wonderful family and friends to support me, and I don’t want to weigh them or myself down with prolonged upset.
Life is too short to waste precious time wallowing in worry. And I’ve learned that courage isn’t the absence of fear — it’s being afraid but doing what you need to do anyway.