As the number of reported bedbug infestations rises and the demand for specially trained dogs to sniff them out soars, so too are complaints from people who say dogs have falsely alerted to bedbugs that were not there. And within the bedbug industry, there are fears that a rise in so called "false positives" by...
NEW YORK — If any heroes have emerged in the bedbug epidemic sweeping households, movie theaters, retailers, schools, offices, you-name-it nationwide, it is surely the bedbug-sniffing dogs.
Cute, diligent and armed with highly sophisticated detection tools — their noses — these dogs are fast becoming the American equivalent of the St. Bernard rescuing the snowbound in the Alps. Commercials vaunt bedbug-sniffing dogs’ prowess and purport up to 98 percent accuracy. In New York, a bedbug-sniffing beagle named Roscoe has become so well known — he has a Facebook page and now an iPhone app — that fellow beagles often are mistaken for him on the street.
But as the number of reported infestations rises and the demand for the dogs soars, complaints from people who say dogs have given false alerts to bedbugs are also climbing. And within the bedbug industry, where some dog trainers and sellers are on back order until next spring despite the dogs’ $11,000 price tag, there are fears that a rise in so-called false positives by dogs will harm their credibility and business.
“Many pest-control companies have the same frustration,” said Michael F. Potter, an entomology professor at the University of Kentucky, “that they often follow behind dogs that are indicating bedbugs, and they can’t find anything.”
Most Read Life Stories
- A popular Seattle-area hike is getting a face-lift. Here’s what’s going on at Rattlesnake Ledge
- Little Saigon might lose 2 big-name restaurants due to lack of walk-in traffic, and 9 other Seattle-area closures
- Fancy Indian food, a hot new vegan place and 25 other new restaurant openings in Seattle
- Rant and Rave: Reader annoyed by the mispronunciation of 'W'
- Vegan sweet potato biscuits bring soft, fluffy warmth to your holiday table
In a co-op near Union Square in Manhattan, a dog indicated bedbugs in a third of the 50-odd apartments, although physical traces of bedbugs were found in only five, according to one resident. He resisted pressure from the co-op board to get a $1,500 treatment because his family had not been bitten by or seen traces of bugs. A designer on the Upper West Side of Manhattan said a dog brought in by her co-op to inspect every apartment had alerted to bedbugs in her home even though neither she nor her husband had been bitten. An inspection by a different exterminator revealed no bedbugs, but her building paid thousands of dollars for apartments to be treated, including those where bedbugs had not been found.
Jessica Silver and her husband paid $3,500 in extermination fees after a dog indicated there were bedbugs throughout their row house in Brooklyn. They got rid of 40 garbage bags full of clothes and baby toys that they feared were infested and their Pottery Barn queen-size bed. But Silver continued to get bitten, and she called another exterminator, John Furman of Boot-a-Pest, based on Long Island, who spent two hours combing through her bedroom, where the biting was taking place, only to find no traces of bedbugs, alive or dead.
The culprits, she eventually discovered, were rodent mites. Furman said the anti-bedbug treatment probably killed some mites but failed to eradicate their breeding grounds in the walls.
Silver did not want to name the bedbug-sniffing dog company she used. After she posted details of her case on an online bedbug forum, she said a company representative threatened to sue her for slander, and the forum moderator took her post down.
“Everyone’s getting sucked into the whole bedbug pandemonium,” Silver said.
While many dog companies advertise an accuracy rate of 95 percent to 98 percent, that figure is taken from a 2008 clinical trial conducted under controlled conditions by an entomology team at the University of Florida. The findings do not necessarily reflect the success rate of individual companies’ dogs, operating in the real world with a lot more variables.
Dog experts say false positives can result from the poor training of a dog or its handler. The dog might become alert to a different type of insect. Or the dog could be reacting to a cue from its handler, be it accidental, like reaching for a treat to reward the dog, or, more ominously, on purpose. Pepe Peruyero, a trainer who runs the J&K Canine Academy near Gainesville, Fla., said if the dog’s company also offered extermination treatment, it was “financially advantageous” to have a dog alert.
False alerts can also be made by well-trained, highly attenuated dogs. Andrew Klein of Assured Environments, based in New York, said dogs might pick up on bedbug scents transmitted by clothes or wafting through ventilation from a neighboring apartment.
“The dog can’t tell us gradations of intensity,” Klein said. “If there is no bug, if there is no bite, we monitor.”
The apartment in Union Square had bedbugs a year earlier; though the bugs were eradicated, it was possible their scent remained. The owner of that apartment, as well as the Upper West Side designer, spoke on condition of anonymity because they did not want their names associated with bedbugs, but others in their buildings also said that dogs had indicated bedbugs even though no physical evidence of the bugs was found.
Some also believed their co-op boards overreacted by paying to treat their apartments.
“You’re under pressure to go the extra step even if you don’t think it’s warranted,” said a lawyer who lives in the same building as the designer, who also spoke on condition of anonymity. “It’s you against the dog.”
Bell Environmental Services, which performed the inspection in both buildings, said that just because bedbugs could not be found did not mean the dog was wrong. The bedbugs could move or be hidden, the company said, and up to 50 percent of people experienced no reaction from bedbug bites.
Physical evidence is especially hard to see. A newly hatched bedbug is the size of a pen tip; fecal droppings are the size of an ink dot.
“The search for a bedbug can be similar to trying to find a moving needle in a haystack,” the company said in a statement.
Bell, which is the owner of Roscoe, added that it explicitly warned customers when its technicians had not corroborated dog alerts with physical evidence and that the decision to treat is made only by co-op boards or residents. If its findings are questioned, Bell offers to send in a second dog to inspect areas where dogs have detected but not found bedbugs, the company said, and uses dogs that are constantly trained to sniff out bedbugs and distinguish them from other insects.
It is unclear how often false positives occur or lead to expensive extermination treatments (there are also cases of false negatives, when bedbugs are present but not detected). The state consumer protection boards in New York and New Jersey said they had no records of complaints, including complaints of false positives, made against companies that use bedbug-sniffing dogs.
Peruyero, the dog trainer, is pushing for scent-detection dogs to be certified through an independent oversight board, the National Entomology Scent Detection Canine Association. But there is factionalism and fighting within the industry, said Philip G. Koehler, an entomologist at the University of Florida, over which association, if any, should certify the dogs.
“The bedbug thing has grown so rapidly that it’s grown ahead of the regulations,” Koehler said.