On the local steakhouse spectrum, Zane + Wylie’s is closer to JaK’s Grill than Metropolitan Grill, says restaurant critic Providence Cicero.
What does it say about a steakhouse when seafood is its stronger game? I enjoyed my steak at Zane + Wylie’s Seattle Steakhouse, but the caviar pie, razor clam chowder, broiled oysters, grilled shrimp and hazelnut-crusted halibut are more likely to bring me back.
That the seafood is so on point isn’t surprising. Chef Kevin Davis secured that niche way back when he was executive chef for five years at Oceanaire Seafood Room. After that tour of duty, he and his wife, Terresa Davis, dropped anchor at Pike Place Market with Steelhead Diner. In 2010, they launched Blueacre Seafood from the slip where Oceanaire once docked. Zane + Wylie’s, named after their school-age sons, is right across the street. (Belltown’s Italian-influenced Orfeo and Tempesta Coffee & Donuts are also part of the family.)
On the local steakhouse spectrum, Zane + Wylie’s is closer to JaK’s Grill than Metropolitan Grill. The prime steaks and chops on the dinner menu are either grilled or cooked on a plancha. The rib-eye appeared to have come from the latter. Cooked to the specified medium-rare, the steak had a hard sear on top and bottom, but no char around the edge. An imposing double-cut pork chop had noticeable grill marks. It was oven-finished, though still quite rare at the bone. The package prices ($34 for the pork chop, $48 for the rib-eye, $46 for the New York strip or tenderloin, $52 for lamb chops) include a house salad, sautéed vegetables and a baked potato preloaded with sour cream, green onion, cheddar cheese and bacon. Not a bad deal if the sides and sauces measured up.
I’d read some Yelping about the puny potato. My companion agreed; he also thought it light on the cargo. It is quite a bit smaller than one of Michael Jordan’s Nikes, but I found the size adequate. I had other peeves: The salad, though well-stocked, was un-tossed; the “sautéed” vegetables (mostly cauliflower and broccoli) looked and tasted steamed and were still hard. A sauce boat of melted garlic butter that was also part of the deal improved the vegetables. A chutney-like apricot-and-raisin agrodolce comes gratis with the pork. It was so good I took the leftover portion home and finished it with breakfast. Other sauces, for which you pay a little extra, included a curdled bearnaise and a thin, peppery gravy billed as “green peppercorn sauce au poivre.”
Most Read Life Stories
- Attention, Amazon employees and all of Seattle: Something amazing just happened in South Lake Union eating VIEW
- Meet the Seattle Labradoodle who landed on a list of 'wackiest pet names'
- Two small Seattle spots make Bon Appetit's big list of 50 best new restaurants
- Neither Popeyes nor Chick-fil-A: Here's where you can find the best fried-chicken sandwich in Seattle
- Day Tripper: Head to Port Townsend for Parisian-style pastries, local brews, wood-fired pizza and plenty of vintage charm VIEW
A steak sandwich and a burger are less expensive dinner alternatives, if it’s beef you’re after. The unfussy burger is a winner. It comes stacked with the essentials — a hand-formed wagyu beef patty, good bacon, aioli. Pickles, onion, lettuce and tomato are on the side amid a pile of fries. I was impressed when the waiter said they use prime N.Y. strip for the steak sandwich. (“There are no crappy cuts here,” he said.) Underneath the peppers, onions and provolone, there was indeed very good meat, so why not slice it rather than chop it randomly, gristle and all?
The burger and the steak sandwich appear on the newly introduced lunch menu, along with a steak salad and wagyu hanger steak frites. But the lunch roster also incorporates some dinner entrees that are downsized and lower-priced. Neah Bay halibut with roasted potatoes, for example, was a $38 entree at night, but only $18 at lunch for a portion that did not seem at all meager. The fish was well-served both by its mantle of hazelnuts, breadcrumbs and cheese, and the vivid green herb sauce swirling around it. At lunch, too, you’ll find one of the best kale salads around. The slivered greens, tossed with lots of chopped pickled vegetables, briny olives and lemon, are a fitting grandstand for three jumbo grilled Gulf shrimp.
Starters are the same day or night. Do order the warm, soft, molasses bread. Each individual loaf comes with salted, honey-dappled butter. New England-style razor clam chowder goes easy on the cream and the herbs, heavier on the bacon and potatoes. Mine lacked the “truffle oil drizzle,” but I didn’t miss it. Great baked oysters from Barron Point brim with garlic butter, bacon crumbles and a touch of Parmesan. Caviar pie nearly duplicates the original I remember fondly from Steelhead Diner’s early days. A wedge of it — chopped hard-cooked egg on the bottom, cream cheese and sour cream in the middle and big pearls of wild salmon roe on top, shored up with chopped capers, red onion and whole grain toast — is a delightful indulgence.
Sides are portioned to share. Be sure to get the green beans, seared to golden-brown tenderness, crunchy with roasted hazelnuts and zesty with orange. Be wary of escarole cooked far past “wilted.” When it comes to pastry chef Jessica Campbell’s desserts, especially her key lime chiffon pie and a cherry tart with white-chocolate ice cream and crème anglaise, maybe order one of each; you won’t want to give up a bite.
Zane + Wylie’s replaced the short-lived, froufrou Circadia. The décor has morphed from raunch to ranch. Gone are the crystal chandeliers and the turquoise velvet upholstery. Now there is earth-toned leatherette covering the barrel-shaped booths, drum-shaded overhead lighting and wood paneling where wallpaper once shimmered. The Davises banished linens and draperies and reinforced the macho vibe with a mural of wranglers on horseback from the “Cowboy Series” by American photographer Laura Wilson. The place looks like the sort of restaurant Seattleites would actually wander into. I hope many will.
Zane + Wylie’s Seattle Steakhouse ★★
624 Olive Way
Seattle, WA 98101
Hours: lunch 11 a.m.-4 p.m. Monday-Friday; dinner 4-10 p.m. daily; happy hour 3-6 p.m. daily
Prices: $$$$ (starters $8-$18, sandwiches and lunch entrees $14-$24, dinner entrees $18-$52)
Drinks: full bar; Northwest spirits, wines and tap beers
Service: high-spirited, attentive
Parking: several nearby garages
Credit cards: all major
Access: no obstacles to entrance; wheelchair lift to lower-level restrooms