The favorite cocktail for fall and winter, the old-fashioned lends itself to many varieties. Here are 12 that bartenders in Seattle and Bellevue are serving.
By mid-November, we cast aside the Moscow Mule for the Old Fashioned.
It’s our cocktail for fall and winter.
A sipper, not a thirst quencher, the old-fashioned is boozy. It packs heat — perfect for this dreary weather.
Most Read Life Stories
- This Seattle restaurant was just named one of the top 12 best new restaurants in the world
- No 'party fouls': The do's and don'ts of vaccinated get-togethers
- Help us, readers: What does 'cheugy' mean? Is Seattle cheugy?
- 25 new restaurant and bar openings around the Greater Seattle area
- Rant and Rave: Reader shares a warming restaurant experience
It consists of booze (usually bourbon or rye), sugar, bitters and water.
It’s a tried-and-true template. Swap out whiskey for an aged rum; it’s winter in Martinique. Use a sweet spirit with chocolate bitters and zest: it’s dessert in a glass.
You can play with that template for hours, and by the look of happy-hour menus lately, bartenders have. Below are 12 variations on the classic cocktail English writer Kingsley Amis called “the only cocktail really to rival the martini and its variants.”
Talented barman Dustin Haarstad wanted to make this Capitol Hill bar more Japanese-whiskey focused, but I never imagined that would include a Waygu beef Old Fashioned. It’s as if a Bloody Mary and pho had a love child.
The drink is an homage to the famous bacon-fat and maple syrup Old Fashioned at New York’s PDT bar. Beef has been infused into the whiskey, the malt smoothing out the beef flavor to create a subtle, savory sipper.
1449 E. Pine St., Seattle (206-294-5230 or nakaseattle.com)
The Cloud Room
Jay Kuehner is the most creative bartender in the region. He does a South American take on this American classic, reducing chicha morada, a purple-corn punch, into a sweet syrup to pair with pisco, a brandy. Two dashes of Peruvian Amargo Chuncho bitters are added to accentuate the cinnamon notes. There’s none of the oak you usually get from an Old Fashioned. It’s a well-thought-out drink, beautifully structured, soft floral notes with the richness of an eau de vie. His Calma Chicha Old Fashioned is garnished with frozen purple grapes, a cinnamon stick and an orange peel.
1424 11th Ave., Seattle (206-739-9004)
After bourbon and rye, aged rum arguably makes the best Old Fashioned. The spices from that spirit scream fall. Rumba’s new bar manager, Tommy Stearns, formerly of Canon and Foreign National, offers a variation that may become its signature winter drink. A boozy bonanza, it’s made with 13 different rums, some from pre-batched house blends.
1112 Pike St., Seattle (206-583-7177 or rumbaonpike.com)
This blend of five different rums and muscovado syrup (anise, cinnamon, tonka bean, cardamom and mace) summons the tropics, but then this drink island-hops to Scotland with a half ounce of Caol Ila 12-year-old Single Malt, giving “The Drifter’s Old Fashioned” a savory tinge. Chocolate mole bitters and lemon go nicely with the peaty scotch to create one of the more sophisticated variations in Seattle.
300 E. Pike St., Seattle (foreignnationalbar.com)
On paper, this drink — rye and Batavia Arrack — shouldn’t work. The funky, rice-based Batavia Arrack is challenging to mix with. But bartender Derek Jeffries pulls it off. He uses a big, spicy rye to complement the molasses in the Batavia Arrack and adds chocolate and aromatic bitters to create his “Voodoo Child” Old Fashioned.
1406 12th Ave., Seattle (tavernlaw.com)
Bourbon is mixed with allspice dram, a liqueur that tastes like the spices from an apple pie. I love the subtle backdrop of cacao and ginseng-like root notes from the Saler French liqueur and the chocolate bitters in this festive “Forager” cocktail.
Two locations: 607 Summit Ave. E., Seattle, and 514 E. Pike St., Seattle (sunliquor.com)
This is what a Fireball cinnamon-whiskey shot would taste like if it dressed up as an Old Fashioned. Spicy and zesty, Cursed Oak’s variation marries the peppery Rittenhouse Rye with a fiery habanero shrub. The brown sugar and orange zest make it go down easy. Let the drink mellow out for a few minutes if you can’t handle the heat.
2137 Second Ave., Seattle (206-485-7385 or on Facebook)
Lot No. 3
Bartenders often fly to distilleries in Kentucky to pick their own barrels so that their bars can offer distinctive whiskeys different from competitors. It’s often served in the bar’s signature Old Fashioned. At Lot No. 3 in Bellevue, the Knob Creek single barrel No. 3438 is served with a silky, spiced vanilla gomme syrup to accentuate the oak and caramel of that sweet whiskey.
460 106th Ave. N.E., Bellevue (425-440-0025 or lotno3.com)
Bastille Cafe & Bar
Arguably the most popular Old Fashioned in Ballard, this French riff fuses Four Roses Yellow bourbon with orgeat syrup and absinthe for a dry, doughy almond-biscotti taste. (Some might argue this drink hews closer to the recipe for an old drink called “The Whiskey Cocktail,” but it shares the DNA of an Old Fashioned.)
5307 Ballard Ave. N.W., Seattle (206-453-5014 or bastilleseattle.com)
This acclaimed Belltown bar features a Christmas-themed drink every day during its Advent cocktail calendar in December. One of its most popular is the Walnut Old Fashioned. Lots of Christmassy components: Calvados, walnut liqueur and Angostura Bitters. It’s a nice change-up from the usual eggnog and candy-cane concoctions that pop up during the holidays.
2332 Second Ave., Seattle (robroyseattle.com)
The bar’s “The Usual” is a rye Old Fashioned with the usual caramel and orange notes. The twist here is the rooty and licorice flavors that come from Amaro Nardini and some autumn notes from cardamom bitters.
1103 First Ave., Seattle (206-582-3505 or heartwoodsea.com)
The Truffle Old Fashioned is destined to be a Seattle winter classic, a decadent drink that appears a few weeks before Christmas at Canon.
In lesser hand, truffles would be suffocating in a cocktail, but barman Jamie Boudreau is an old hand at this game. He infuses black truffles with cognac, and he structures the drink with subtle vanilla, cacao and coffee notes (from tonka-bean syrup and Boker’s bitters).
928 12th Ave., Seattle (206-552-9755 or canonseattle.com)