Schools in Washington suspend thousands of elementary-school students each year, but doing so rarely changes bad behavior. How to find school discipline that works?
For years, Franky terrified his teachers.
As a third-grader, he pantomimed killing other students by sliding his finger across his throat. In fourth grade, he swore at anyone who angered him. The worst moment came one month into fifth grade, after Franky wrote down his violent fantasies.
He never planned to act on any of them, but the behavior alarmed educators enough to get him suspended from the Clover Park School District, then expelled from Tillicum — placing him among the thousands of children statewide who are removed annually from elementary-school classrooms.
More about Education Lab
To Franky, the punishments barely registered. Raised in a family of drug users and dealers, he wandered with them from one dingy apartment to the next. Often, there was no bed to sleep on and nothing but plastic covering the windows.
This is the third in a series of Education Lab stories exploring the problems of school discipline and how school districts are working to alleviate them. The first two:
Franky never told anyone. He knew it would mean foster care.
Instead, he acted out, finally scrawling his inner world onto a piece of notepaper that another student showed their teacher.
Most Read Stories
- For a really big show in your garden, plant these giant perennials — and then stand back
- Single word sparks crossfire between Supreme Court, NPR and its star reporter Nina Totenberg
- Toxic PCBs festered at a Monroe school for eight years as students, teachers grew sicker
- John Stockton’s defiance of COVID-19 mask mandate forces Gonzaga to suspend Hall of Famer’s season tickets
- Why a giant fog cloud is parked over Seattle area, and when it will clear
“He took one look at me and said, ‘You need to go,’ ” recalled Franky, now a senior at Chief Sealth High School. “Honestly, I’m surprised [Child Protective Services] wasn’t called — how does a fifth-grader even know about the things I was writing? I wish someone would have pulled me aside and asked: ‘Why do you feel this way?’ I mean, I was only 10 years old. But it was just ‘Go, get out of here.’ ”
Franky’s experience is not uncommon. In Washington, school suspension starts with kids as young as 5 years old, often beginning a downward spiral. Data show that certain children are punished again and again — missing weeks of class without a noticeable change in behavior. A third-grader from Seattle’s Highland Park Elementary, for example, was suspended nine times last year.
Such trends, only recently tracked, are raising serious concerns among legal advocates, parents and others who say schools rely too often on punitive discipline, especially for the very young.
“They’re whole children and they have behaviors,” said Jennifer Harris, policy analyst for the Education Ombuds, a state agency that mediates between families and schools. “That’s what we’re supposed to be teaching them — that there are rules. But instead, we’re tossing them out of school. I’ve got a 5-year-old being written up as a sexual harasser. I know about 5- or 6-year-olds who’ve hit their teacher’s wrist and that’s cast as assault.”
Bad behavior as sign of child’s mental state
In general, elementary-school suspensions follow the same pattern as discipline for older students: a surprising number of kids sent home for lesser offenses like disrespect, and black children suspended at rates that far outpace their enrollment.
Explanations for the latter fall, roughly, into two camps: those who say African-American kids, like Franky, more often flout schoolhouse norms; and those who insist that mostly-white educators frequently escalate misunderstandings into punishment.
But when it comes to suspensions, growing research suggests there is a less contentious — and more productive — way to handle students, one that views misbehavior not as a personal attack but as a language signaling children’s neurological state.
Teaching through this lens has given educators a powerful new tool for handling difficult outbursts, and it is getting results in schools from Boston to Los Angeles, including 12 in Washington state. Teachers in at least one Spokane school have watched suspensions drop by half.
Such an approach could have been transformational for Franky. Because for all the fear he caused in teachers, it is teachers he remembers most fondly. Compared with his life outside of school, they were the safest people he knew.
ACEs are common
About 2,100 students in 10 Spokane elementary schools were evaluated to determine their level of Adverse Childhood Experiences. More than 75 percent of the students were white. About half were poor. The results:
• Parents separated/divorced: 36 percent
• Residential instability: 9 percent
• Witnessed domestic violence: 9 percent
• Child Protective Services: 9 percent
• Family member jailed: 9 percent
• Substance abuse in family: 7 percent
• Lack of food, clothes, other basics: 7 percent
• Mental-health disorders in family: 5 percent
• Physical disability in family: 3 percent
• Exposed to community violence: 3 percent
• Death of parent/caregiver: 2 percent
Source: Washington State University Area Health Project
Put simply, certain experiences — including events as common as divorce — can be traumatic for children and harm their prefrontal cortexes, the part of the brain in charge of self-control and abstract reasoning. As a result, kids who grow up in chaotic or unstable homes may appear unfocused in class or react to off-the-cuff remarks as threats — precisely the sorts of behavior coded “disruptive” or “disrespectful” on school discipline spreadsheets.
“It’s as if their hair’s on fire, and you’re asking them to write their name,” said Kristy Wilkinson, who teaches third grade in Spokane, where research suggests at least 45 percent of students are growing up in homes riven by alcoholism, mental illness, domestic violence and other types of family dysfunction.
The light bulb came on for Wilkinson when she learned that kids from such households exist in a simmering state of emergency — which shows up in school as impulsivity, edginess and aggression.
“I realized that my students’ behavior wasn’t about me — it was about their story,” she said. “Taking that personal aspect out of the equation was huge.”
Wilkinson’s epiphany came not via feel-good theorists, but brain science spurred by the findings of two physicians who in 1997 discovered a link between what they called Adverse Childhood Experiences — or ACEs — and adult health problems.
Factoring in trauma’s effect on learning
The original study, by Drs. Robert Anda, with the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and Vincent Felitti, of Kaiser Permanente in San Diego, focused on 17,000 patients — most of them white, middle-class and educated, who reported rates of childhood trauma that surprised investigators: Nearly two-thirds had experienced at least one ACE (often, parental divorce), and 22 percent noted three or more, including substance abuse and domestic violence.
Those findings intrigued Chris Blodgett, a public-health researcher at Washington State University, who began examining school results through the ACEs lens, and believes racism could also be added to the child-trauma list. Poverty, too, is absent from the nine life events officially tracked. But it often exists alongside them.
Either way, the upshot was clear: trauma interferes with brain systems essential to learning, and the more ACEs, the more trauma. In 2014, Johns Hopkins University published similar results.
“If this data was coming from middle-class white adults, we knew we had it in our schools,” said Wendy Bleeker, director of student support in Spokane. “It’s clear that kids are experiencing trauma. It’s clear that it’s affecting their attendance and learning. So it made sense for us to get ahead of it.”
Discipline that works: A community conversation
Education Lab invites you to a conversation on school discipline this Wednesday at South Seattle College. Speakers are Garfield High Principal Ted Howard, Kentwood High teacher Jay Maebori and Seattle student Dayöne Florence. Light dinner at 5:30 p.m.; program at 6:30 p.m. Registration required at seati.ms/disciplineforall. Free.
The notion of Adverse Childhood Experiences resonated loudly at Bemiss Elementary, which is largely white and sits in one of the poorest ZIP codes in Washington. Until recently, Bemiss suspended more than 100 kids each year.
“Suspension was huge here,” said Jen Moore, a school psychologist. “It was just, ‘Get this kid out of my class.’ ”
In 2008, Bemiss became one of Blodgett’s early laboratories. First, his team educated teachers about the effects of early trauma, then helped them come up with ways to mitigate it.
Predictability, they learn, is helpful for kids with chaotic lives. At Bemiss, this shows up as daily schedules posted with large, colorful letters; student-behavior charts that progress from “super job” to “think about it” to “parent contact”; and secluded corners where children can sit and calm themselves.
You are more than your mistakes, says a poster in the quiet area just outside Wilkinson’s classroom.
Forging genuine relationships — among teachers, and between students and adults — also works. That may sound obvious, acknowledged Principal Jennifer Keck, but in many teacher-training programs it comes as an afterthought.
“So much is focused on instructional strategies — how to teach reading, how to teach math or science — but I firmly believe if we haven’t built the relationships, you won’t have instruction as rigorous as you want,” she said.
After five years of incorporating these and similar approaches, Keck watched suspensions drop by 33 percent in 2014, without forcing teachers to simply endure disruptive students. Indeed, school records show that defiance plummeted between September and April this school year.
From concept to classroom
That climate is evident in Bemiss Elementary’s cheery hallways, where teachers routinely throw an arm around students — even the most obstreperous. While test scores have bounced up and down, Bemiss is the first high-poverty school in Spokane to make it to the state finals in robotics last year.
Keck and her team walked a long road to get to this point. It took four years of monthly training and a team of teachers willing to collaborate on trauma-sensitive approaches.
I realized that my students’ behavior wasn’t about me — it was about their story. Taking that personal aspect out of the equation was huge.”
“Early on, they used to ask: ‘Give us that silver bullet. Show us what to do.’ But it was not about me as a school leader deciding that,” Keck said. “It was about coming together as a staff and pooling what we knew about kids. It takes a while.”
Not to say that Bemiss students no longer challenge their teachers.
A fourth-grader sitting outside Keck’s office — arms crossed hard across his chest, hoodie zipped over his head and body pretzel-twisted into a tight little line — provided a recent example. He was a bottle-rocket about to explode, a live wire of rage.
Years ago the boy almost certainly would have been suspended. He had scribbled on another child’s work, thrown a marker at his teacher and stormed from the classroom.
Peggy Slotvig, who knew the child and happened to be on a break, did not immediately grill him about why he’d been sent out of class. Instead, she ushered the youth upstairs, away from front-office traffic and into an empty classroom where the two sat close together.
“We were just messing around,” he began in a high voice, describing his fight with the art teacher. “Then she said, ‘That’s no way to get a girlfriend,’ and it set me off.”
“Very good — it did set you off. Because it embarrassed you,” nodded Slotvig, aware that the student had been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, and no longer speaks to his mother.
“She started it,” the youth insisted, rocking slightly in his chair.
“You know what? I’m going to agree with you — she did start it,” Slotvig said. “But not to be mean. She was trying to be funny. She just didn’t know your triggers.”
It would be the boy’s responsibility to explain them, just as he had with the librarian and gym teacher, and to answer for losing his temper. Consequences are essential, notes Natalie Turner, a trainer on Blodgett’s team who worked with the Bemiss staff.
“There is a place for suspension,” she said. “There has to be accountability. But too often, that response is purely reactive. It’s not about problem-solving.”
Back in Seattle, this organic approach to addressing behavior intrigued Vicki Sacco, principal at West Seattle Elementary, which has the highest rate of public-housing students in the city and suspended 13 kids last year.
That places it sixth among Seattle elementary schools, a significant improvement from 2010, when Sacco arrived to see children lining the hallway outside the principal’s office. But she wants more.
Last summer, teachers at West Seattle invited Blodgett’s team to begin schooling them, work funded through a $650,000 grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. (Note: The Education Lab project also receives support from the foundation.)
“I felt that the staff was ready for this kind of self-reflection,” Sacco said. “Programs come and go, but they don’t really require you to grow as a professional. This was different. It was helping teachers look within themselves. You know, we do take things personally — we’re human. But reacting that way can make things so much worse.”
Turner, the trainer, now makes monthly visits to West Seattle. After working with teachers she visits students, showing each class the relationship between feelings, actions and ways to manage them.
In a roomful of fifth-graders last month she made a fist to model their brains. Her thumb, tucked inside, was the hippocampus, the center for emotions.
“Show me where you feel your feelings,” she told the kids.
Some pointed to their heads, others to their hearts. One poked at his stomach.
“That’s right,” said Turner, seizing an opportunity. “Our brains are giving our bodies clues that we’re about to have a really big feeling. Raise your hand if you ever get stressed out.”
Every child in the room shot a hand in the air.
“Raise your hands if there is someone outside of school you can talk to about those feelings,” Turner continued.
Half the class sat motionless.
Editor’s Note: This story was altered on May 04, 2018. A full name reference in the story was changed. After careful consideration the Times felt the alteration did not hurt the accuracy or value of the story and provided more protection for those participating in it.