As the summer concert season starts, music fans and the industry that serves them, have a common enemy in New York. And in Russia. And in India.
That enemy is the bot.
“Bots,” computer programs used by advanced scalpers, are a hidden part of a miserable ritual that plays out online nearly every week in which tickets to hot shows seem to vanish instantly. Long a mere nuisance to the live-music industry, these cheap and widely available programs are now perhaps its most reviled foe, frustrating fans and feeding a multibillion-dollar secondary market for tickets.
According to Ticketmaster, bots have been used to buy more than 60 percent of the most desirable tickets for some shows. In a recent lawsuit, the company accused one group of scalpers of using bots to request up to 200,000 tickets a day.
Most Read Business Stories
- Flawed analysis, failed oversight: How Boeing, FAA certified the suspect 737 MAX flight control system | Times Watchdog
- Belltown penthouse is region’s priciest condo sale ever — and new owners won't even live there
- Amazon real estate exec says Bellevue plan not affected by New York exit
- Doomed jets lacked 2 key safety features that Boeing sold only as extras
- Airline threats to cancel Boeing MAX orders may just be a bargaining tactic
Ticketmaster and its parent company, Live Nation Entertainment, have stepped up efforts to combat bots. The result has been a game of cat and mouse.
“As with hackers, you can solve it today, and they’re rewriting code tomorrow,” said Michael Rapino, Live Nation’s chief executive. “Thus the arms race.”
In 2011, Ticketmaster hired John Carnahan, a machine-learning expert who had fought online-ad scams at Yahoo, to lead its anti-bot effort. By monitoring the behavior of each visitor to Ticketmaster’s site, the company can determine the likelihood of a customer being human or a machine.
For example, a human may click a series of buttons at a range of speeds and in different spots on a screen, but bots can give themselves away by rapidly clicking on precisely the same spot.
A screen on Carnahan’s desk in Los Angeles shows Ticketmaster’s incoming traffic, with a rainbow of colors at the bottom and splotches of red on top representing suspicious activity. On a recent Thursday, the screen showed that the red visitors were making 600 times more ticket requests than those identified as being most likely human.
Bots are not kicked off the system but rather “speedbumped” — slowed down, sent to the end of the line or given some other means of interference, to allow a regular customer through.
“We’re not trying to stop anybody from buying tickets,” Carnahan said. “We’re just trying to make sure that a fan can buy the tickets.”
Ticketing bots are often inexpensive and programmed in countries beyond easy reach of U.S. law enforcement. Rob Rachwald of the computer-security company FireEye, which is not working with Ticketmaster, points out that one site — available in English and Russian — charges just $13.90 for the keys to 10,000 Captchas, those squiggly lines that test whether a potential customer is human.
In January, Ticketmaster replaced most of its old Captchas with newer and more sophisticated versions. The company is also introducing a system for mobile devices that aims to eliminate Captcha-style tests altogether.
Live Nation will not say how many of the 148 million tickets it sells each year are bought using bots, and in many cases it may not know. Official groups like the National Association of Ticket Brokers, which represents many of the biggest resellers, condemn them and say they support anti-bot measures.
But people at nearly every level of the concert business blame bots for wreaking all kinds of economic havoc.
“There are sold-out shows in reserved-seat houses in New York City where we will have 20 percent no-show, and that 20 percent will be down in the front of the house,” said Jim Glancy of The Bowery Presents, an independent concert promoter. “It’s speculators who bought a bunch of seats and didn’t get the price they wanted.”
Concert promoters, artist managers and ticketing services say bots are now an ever-present force, not only during the high-traffic moments when a big show officially goes on sale, but also at the odd moments when a promoter releases a few dozen extra seats with no announcement.
Darlene Schild, of Lincroft, N.J., may have experienced the reach of bots when she tried to buy Justin Bieber tickets as an 11th-birthday present for her daughter. She fired up TicketMaster’s iPhone app just as the tickets went on sale, but after 15 fruitless minutes gave up.
“The first thing that crossed my mind was that some ticket-buying service bought them all,” Schild said. “Or someone could dial quicker than me. Some technology — something.”
Last month, Ticketmaster sued 21 people in federal court, accusing them of fraud, copyright infringement and other offenses in using bots to search for millions of tickets over the last two years.
The legal status of bots is unclear. They are banned in a handful of states, but those laws have proved largely ineffectual.
Three years ago, four men connected with a company called Wiseguy Tickets were indicted on conspiracy, wire fraud and other charges, for allegedly using bots to get tickets to Bruce Springsteen, Hannah Montana and other concerts. The case hinged on whether the men had committed actual crimes or had merely violated Ticketmaster’s terms of service.
In the end three of the men were sentenced only to probation and community service (one remained at large).
Not everyone is convinced that bots are the primary villain of the everyday concertgoer. The Fan Freedom Project, a nonprofit group financed by StubHub, has pushed for anti-bot laws, and its president, Jon Potter, praised Ticketmaster for suing.
But he also criticized the industry practice of “holds,” in which sometimes large blocks of tickets are reserved for sponsors, fan-club members and industry contacts, and never go on sale to the general public.
When it comes to the secondary ticket market, Live Nation has a complicated position. As much as it is trying to block bots, the company also profits from the ticket resale market through TicketsNow — its own version of StubHub — as well as through deals with major sports groups, like the NBA. Rapino sees no contradiction in Live Nation’s stance.
“I have no problem if you bought a Justin Timberlake ticket and you decide to go sell that ticket to somebody,” he said. “We would first and foremost want to make sure that the first ticket sold, that the fan has a shot to buy that ticket.”