Carly Fiorina's career has followed an uncannily cinematic arc. A restless law-school dropout becomes a master sales rep for Ma Bell, then...
Carly Fiorina’s career has followed an uncannily cinematic arc.
A restless law-school dropout becomes a master sales rep for Ma Bell, then rises higher in business than any other woman, running Hewlett-Packard for six years. She wrestles that stodgy Silicon Valley institution into the Internet age, needing every ounce of her charm to win a huge merger contest.
But her style inflames critics. After her financial results fall short, she is unceremoniously canned.
Most Read Business Stories
- We freaked out over Amazon's HQ2 search. But it turned out to be for all the wrong reasons | Danny Westneat
- U.S. pilots flying 737 MAX weren't told about new automatic systems change linked to Lion Air crash
- Starbucks laying off 350 people, mostly at Seattle headquarters
- Will Amazon's HQ2 sink Seattle's housing market?
- California bar clears lawyer Michael Avenatti of fraud allegations tied to his Tully's business dealings
So if this were a movie, what would happen next?
That’s right: Get ready for Fiorina’s comeback.
In her memoir emerging this week, “Tough Choices,” Fiorina will contend that she was unfairly scrutinized as a woman in business and unproductively opposed by people who feared the big changes she had to make at HP.
“It’s a book about what’s required of change agents,” she told a women-in-business conference recently at Babson College outside Boston. “The agents of change are always resisted. … Some people fear the unknown, whatever it may be, even more than they fear the troublesome but known present.”
On one level, the memoir seems perfectly timed as HP twists amid its current corporate spying scandal, confirming the dysfunctional insecurity of the board that fired Fiorina.
But her opinion is not exactly objective. The board’s extensive efforts to uncloak the source of media leaks began when she was chairwoman and CEO, though investigators eventually mined her phone records as well.
The real reason the timing is fortuitous is that the book provides Fiorina a platform to reinvent herself for whatever comes next.
She has the freedom of choice that comes from being extremely wealthy. Besides her $21 million severance pay, she began 2006 with 850,000 HP shares — a stake that size is worth $31 million now.
Fiorina, 52, told the Babson audience she has maintained her interest in global development issues. Her name emerged last year as a candidate for World Bank president. She has joined the boards of Cybertrust, a computer-security company, and Revolution Health Group, a health-care venture launched by America Online founder Steve Case.
Stephen Mader, vice chairman of Christian & Timbers, the headhunting firm that brought Fiorina from AT&T spin-off Lucent Technologies to HP in 1999, says the ignominious end to her HP stint will not necessarily keep her from becoming a CEO again.
However, Fiorina’s next employer would be wise to study the strengths and weaknesses she showed at HP.
Fiorina wins praise for defining a new vision for a slow-moving bureaucracy that had essentially missed the Internet revolution. Before Fiorina, HP had a murky strategy for linking its computer, server and printer businesses. She recast HP as an IBM-like strategic partner for customers trying to take advantage of the always-on aspects of the Web era.
But generally she is considered to have fallen short on day-to-day operational matters — the things that prompt raves for her successor, Mark Hurd.
When Fiorina was fired in February 2005, HP’s board had repeatedly backed her strategy — including her hard-fought, $19 billion acquisition of Compaq Computer in 2002 — but had grown tired of uneven earnings results. HP’s stock sank 56 percent on her watch.
Among the most famous letdowns: Fiorina told Wall Street that HP could produce 15 percent revenue growth in 2001. It fell 7 percent. In August 2004, when sales fell way short of forecasts, Fiorina blamed embarrassing problems with an internal computer system and surprisingly weak customer demand, then fired three top executives.
“When she got past the first three years of work, her lack of Hurd-type skills — and her perhaps lack of self-awareness about having to inject those skills around her — I think is what started to show the wear and tear. That’s where it started to come apart,” Mader said.
As Fiorina tells it now, she was hampered by perceptions she struggled to change.
“It is still true that women are caricatured and characterized differently from men,” she said.
She cites inaccurate rumors that she had a pink marble bathroom in her HP office and constantly traveled with a hairdresser and a makeup artist. She laments how people complained of her use of a private jet, even though that is standard for men in the business world. (It had been at HP as well, though her predecessor, Lew Platt, had reduced corporate flying to trim costs.)
Dealing with layoffs
One of her other favorite double-standards involves layoffs. She cut at least 15,000 jobs after the Compaq deal; Hurd has whacked a similar amount.
“A woman lays people off, she’s heartless,” Fiorina said. “A man lays people off, he’s decisive.”
Fiorina has long said she disliked tallies of the “most powerful women in business” because there are more important things about leadership to discuss than gender. “Whoever heard of a list of men CEOs ranked against each other?” she said.
But the truth is more complex. She never seemed eager to reject the limelight.
Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, a senior associate dean at Yale’s School of Management, saw Fiorina’s globe-trotting in the spotlight as a reflection of her never having “been outside of backslapping in industrial sales” and was “thrown in over her head” as CEO of a sprawling organization.
His verdict on her tenure: “A reign of terror and poor performance.”
Such assessments don’t faze Fiorina. For one thing, she revels in recent observations that she might deserve some credit for HP’s performance since her departure. The stock is up 86 percent in that time.
Vyomesh Joshi, a 26-year HP veteran who heads its printing division, said Hurd is “doing a great job focusing on the execution” of the long-term strategy Fiorina implemented.
“I think Carly is a great leader,” Joshi said. “She brought along a lot of good changes and she had a powerful vision. I learned a lot from Carly.”
Fiorina also shrugs off the negatives from her HP past by remaining defiantly optimistic, careful to temper bitter notes.
For example, she observes that while she endured plenty of hazing from men in her career — such as an early AT&T colleague who insisted on meeting with a customer at a strip club — some of those same guys eventually became her biggest supporters.
“I feel incredibly blessed,” she said. “I am an unexpected success story to myself.”