Median CEO compensation at S&P 500 companies last year jumped by the most in three years. But at those relatively few companies where “say-on-pay” votes were lukewarm or worse, executives were often punished with reduced pay packages.
NEW YORK — The typical CEO at the biggest U.S. companies got an 8.5 percent raise last year, raking in $11.5 million in salary, stock and other compensation last year, according to a study by executive data firm Equilar for The Associated Press. That’s the biggest raise in three years.
The bump reflects how well stocks have done under these CEOs’ watch. Boards of directors increasingly require that CEOs push their stock price higher to collect their maximum possible payout, and the Standard & Poor’s 500 index returned 12 percent last year.
Over the last five years, median CEO pay in the survey has jumped by 19.6 percent, not accounting for inflation. That’s nearly double the 10.9 percent rise in the typical weekly paycheck for full-time employees across the country.
Special Report: CEO Pay
- What the bosses make: Compare the compensation for 96 Northwest CEOs
- NW CEOs sitting pretty, despite public’s view that they’re paid too much
- Nike’s Mark Parker leads the pack, thanks to a rich stock grant
- Women CEOs rare at U.S. public companies, and even scarcer in Pacific Northwest
- At biggest U.S. companies, CEOs got a nice raise last year
- Few women among nation’s CEOs, but they are well paid
- Extreme compensation has become the norm | Jon Talton
But CEO pay did fall for one group of companies last year: those where investors complained the loudest about executive pay. Compensation dropped for nine of the 10 companies scoring the lowest on “say on pay” votes, where shareholders give thumbs up or down on top executives’ earnings.
Other measures that would highlight the income gap between CEOs and typical workers are on the way, but governance watchdogs worry that Congress will kill or dilute their strength.
“It’s all out of whack right now,” said Heather Slavkin Corzo, director of the AFL-CIO Office of Investment, which says CEOs for major U.S. companies make 347 times more than the average worker.
National top five
The AP’s CEO compensation study includes pay data for 346 executives at S&P 500 companies who have served two full consecutive fiscal years in their posts, at companies that filed proxy statements between January 1 and May 1. (Nike’s annual proxy is filed in late July; the Seattle Times/Equilar Pacific Northwest CEO Pay survey used the one for fiscal 2016, ended May 31 and filed last July.)
The highest-paid executive in the survey was Thomas Rutledge of Charter Communications, which absorbed Time Warner Cable and Bright House Networks last year to become the nation’s second-largest cable operator.
His compensation totaled $98 million, about $88 million of that from stock and option awards included as part of a new five-year employment agreement. For Rutledge to collect the full amount, Charter’s share price will need to rise 155 percent over six years.
CEOs typically got more than half their total compensation from stock and option grants last year.
|The nation’s highest paid CEOs|
|Company||Pay||Change from last year|
|1. Thomas Rutledge||Charter Communications Inc.||$98 million||Up 499 percent|
|2. Leslie Moonves||CBS Corp.||$68.6 million||Up 22 percent|
|3. Robert Iger||Walt Disney Co.||$41 million||Down 6 percent|
|4. David Zaslav||Discovery Communications Inc.||$37.2 million||Up 15 percent|
|5. Robert Kotick||Activision Blizzard Inc.||$33.1 million||Up 358 percent|
|6. Brian Roberts||Comcast Corp.||$33 million||Down 9 percent|
|7. Jeffrey Bewkes||Time Warner Inc.||$32.6 million||Up 3 percent|
|8. Virginia Rometty||IBM||$32.3 million||Up 63 percent|
|9. Leonard Schleifer||Regeneron Pharmaceuticals Inc.||$28.3 million||Down 40 percent|
|10. Stephen Wynn||Wynn Resorts Ltd.||$28.2 million||Up 36 percent|
|Sources: The Associated Press and Equilar|
The lesson from the rest of the top five: how lucrative the entertainment business can be.
No. 2 on the survey was Leslie Moonves at CBS, who made $68.6 million. That included $63.9 million in bonus and stock awards the company’s board said he received for presiding over a 36.6 percent return for CBS shares in 2016 and for keeping CBS the top-rated network in the 2015-16 season, among other performance measures.
No. 3 was Walt Disney’s Robert Iger, at $41 million. That was 6 percent less than the year before, as slowing growth resulted in a bonus cut.
Fourth-highest at $37.2 million was David Zaslav of Discovery Communications, whose networks include TLC and Animal Planet. Roughly 70 percent of that was from stock and option awards.
No. 5 was Activision Blizzard’s Robert Kotick, whose compensation surged 358 percent to $33.1 million. That was almost entirely due to $24.9 million in stock awards he received as part of a new five-year employment agreement. To get them, the company’s earnings per share must hit a certain level, among other financial targets.
Kotick may not make the top five this year. His 2017 salary was cut by 26 percent to $1.8 million after many shareholders said they were upset about how much Activision Blizzard executives were making. The company also eliminated his guarantee for an annual salary increase.
Nay on pay
Kotick’s salary cut demonstrates how companies will revamp pay structures in response to complaints from shareholders.
When the shareholders of Exelon met in Philadelphia for their annual meeting last spring, the energy company asked what they thought about how much CEO Christopher Crane and other executives made in the previous year. Exelon shares had lost 22 percent in 2015.
Shareholders made their displeasure known. Of shares voted, 62 percent were against the compensation or abstained. That’s the highest say-on-pay percentage in this year’s survey.
After the meeting, Exelon made several changes, including capping how much executives can receive in incentive payments if the stock loses money over the year.
Auto supplier BorgWarner had last year’s second-lowest passing rate on say-on- pay, with 60 percent of voting shares saying no or abstaining. The company made changes to its compensation program and cut a 2016 incentive award by $2.4 million to $950,000 for CEO James Verrier. His total compensation dropped 29 percent to $12.3 million last year.
At Chevron, which had the seventh-lowest say-on-pay passing rate, CEO John Watson’s compensation fell 2 percent to $18.8 million. After talking with shareholders, the company said it will cap some bonus awards and make other changes for 2017 compensation.
Boards of directors know they have to pay CEOs similar to what their rivals are making, if not more, compensation experts say.
“They’re very aware of what their peers are doing,” said John Wood, vice chairman of Heidrick & Struggles, a search firm that corporate boards hire to find their next CEO.
When a company gets a poor showing on its say-on-pay vote, though, “companies do take it seriously,” said Kelly Malafis, a partner at Compensation Advisory Partners, an executive-compensation consulting firm. “Even if it’s not failing, but below 70 or 80 percent, companies see that, and they typically respond in the next year.”
That’s why governance experts are concerned to see proposed legislation in Washington, D.C., they say could weaken say-on-pay. Instead of holding the vote at least once every three years, a proposal says it should happen only when executives’ compensation packages have changed “materially” from the previous year. It’s part of a push to loosen regulations on businesses; advocates say that would boost the economy.
“The say-on-pay vote has been a real game changer,” said Amy Borrus, deputy director of the Council of Institutional Investors, which represents pension funds and other big investors that manage $23 trillion in assets. “We think that’s a mistake.”
|Highest paid CEOs by state|
|The survey considered only publicly traded companies with more than $1 billion in revenue that filed their proxy statements with federal regulators between Jan. 1 and May 1. It includes CEOs who have been in place for at least two years. Not every state had a publicly traded company headquartered there that was large enough to be included.|
|Alabama||Grayson Hall||Regions Financial Corp.||$8 million|
|Arizona||Richard C. Adkerson||Freeport-McMoRan Inc.||$14 million|
|Arkansas||Doug McMillon||Wal-Mart Stores||$22.4 million|
|California||Robert A. Iger||Walt Disney Co.||$41 million|
|Colorado||Greg Maffei||Liberty Media Corp. and Interactive Corp.||$30.2 million|
|Connecticut||Tom Rutledge||Charter Communications||$98 million|
|Delaware||Hervé Hoppenot||Incyte||$11.8 million|
|Florida||Brian Jellison||Roper Technologies||$26.3 million|
|Georgia||Ron Clarke||Fleetcor Technologies||$21.7 million|
|Hawaii||Matt Cox||Matson Inc.||$3.9 million|
|Idaho||Darrel Anderson||IDACORP Inc.||$3.5 million|
|Illinois||Richard A. Gonzalez||AbbVie||$18 million|
|Indiana||Joseph Swedish||Anthem||$16.5 million|
|Iowa||Stan Askren||HNI Corp.||$5.9 million|
|Kansas||Michael J. Brown||Euronet Worldwide||$6.4 million|
|Kentucky||Greg Creed||Yum Brands||$15.4 million|
|Louisiana||Glen F. Post III||CenturyLink||$13.6 million|
|Maine||Jonathan Ayers||Idexx Laboratories||$5.9 million|
|Maryland||David Zaslav||Discovery Communications||$37.2 million|
|Massachusetts||Jeffrey R. Immelt||General Electric||$18 million|
|Michigan||Mary Barra||General Motors||$22.4 million|
|Minnesota||Stephen J. Hemsley||UnitedHealth Group||$15.7 million|
|Mississippi||Joe F. Sanderson Jr.||Sanderson Farms||$3.8 million|
|Missouri||Michael F. Neidorff||Centene||$22 million|
|Nebraska||Fredric J. Tomczyk||TD Ameritrade Holding Corp.||$11.4 million|
|Nevada||Stephen A. Wynn||Wynn Resorts||$28.2 million|
|New Hampshire||Tim McGrath||PC Connection||$3.9 million|
|New Jersey||Alex Gorsky||Johnson & Johnson||$21.9 million|
|New Mexico||Pat Vincent-Collawn||PNM Resources||$4 million|
|New York||Leslie Moonves||CBS Corp.||$68.6 million|
|North Carolina||Brian Moynihan||Bank of America||$15.5 million|
|North Dakota||David L. Goodin||MDU Resources Group||$3.3 million|
|Ohio||W. Nicholas Howley||TransDigm Group||$18.7 million|
|Oklahoma||Doug Lawler||Chesapeake Energy||$15.3 million|
|Oregon||Andrew C. Teich||FLIR Systems||$5.1 million|
|Pennsylvania||Brian L. Roberts||Comcast||$33 million|
|Rhode Island||Larry Merlo||CVS Health||$18.4 million|
|South Carolina||John D. Williams||Domtar Corp.||$7.2 million|
|South Dakota||David R. Emery||Black Hills||$4.1 million|
|Tennessee:||Kenneth W. Lowe||Scripps Networks Interactive||$26.8 million|
|Texas||Randall Stephenson||AT&T||$25.3 million|
|Utah||Truman Hunt||Nu Skin Enterprises||$10.3 million|
|Virginia||Marty Barrington,||Altria Group||$24.2 million|
|Washington, D.C.||Thomas P. Joyce Jr.||Danaher||$13 million|
|Washington||Howard Schultz||Starbucks||$21.8 million|
|Wisconsin||Jeffery Yabuki||Fiserv||$21.2 million|
|Sources: The Associated Press and Equilar|