In seven years, the identical twins Drew and Jonathan Scott, 39, have gone from aspiring celebrities on a small Canadian cable network to HGTV headliners.

Share story

Inside a bungalow under renovation in Galveston, Texas, Jonathan Scott, one half of the squeaky-clean Property Brothers, was yanking a toilet out from the floor.

“Let’s do it one more time,” said a producer, watching from a nearby monitor.

Scott walked into the small bathroom again, acting surprised as he spied the toilet. Then he pulled it from the floor.

The scene was being shot for the fifth season of “Brother vs. Brother,” the HGTV program in which the highly competitive Scott brothers use equal sums of their own money (in this case $600,000) to buy, renovate and then sell houses in the same town. All proceeds go to charities like Habitat for Humanity. This Galveston season will make its premiere on May 31.

Scott, who is a perfect mix of rugged and well coifed, a man who gets his work boots dirty even as his hair stays untousled, went for a house that could be considered a major fixer-upper. His identical twin brother, Drew, who is as handsome if not quite as hair-sprayed, and favors suits and ties over Timberlands, opted for a ramshackle heap that was larger and had better access to some of the island’s canals.

“He’s desperate to win,” said Jonathan, who has won on the last two seasons of the show. “I was also born first, so I also won that competition,” he said, a joke typical of the brothers’ repartee both on- and offscreen.

Around the corner, in a different bayside house sitting high up on stilts, Drew was dealing with dislodged materials for his own renovation. The day before, strong winds had ripped a thin metal chimney from the roof. It had landed to the side of the driveway. Now it was time to recreate the scene. “This is a high-intensity moment,” a production assistant whispered.

The director called to the house, “I need some workers out front!” A crew of tradesmen walked out onto a second-floor porch and pretended to work.

“Bang!” the director said.

Drew ran from the house. He looked at the chimney with feigned shock. He rubbed his eyes.

“Let’s do the run out again,” the director said.

Drew walked back inside and ran out again. He pretended to notice the chimney again, and looked up toward the workmen. “Go inside, guys! I don’t want you to work outside; it’s too windy!”

The workers went back inside, and then came back out, and went in, for a third take.

“At the end of the day, it has to be interesting television,” Drew said later. “But when we find a load-bearing wall, we are really finding a load-bearing wall.”

Drew Scott of the Property Brothers, far right, preparing to shoot a scene for the fifth season of “Brother vs. Brother.” (Todd Spoth for The New York Times)
Drew Scott of the Property Brothers, far right, preparing to shoot a scene for the fifth season of “Brother vs. Brother.” (Todd Spoth for The New York Times)

At a time when politics have riven the nation, an old-fashioned, wholesome shelter show is something many can agree on. In seven years, Drew and Jonathan Scott, 39, have gone from aspiring celebrities on a small Canadian cable network to HGTV headliners who star in, and in some cases produce, some of the most popular television shows in America.

They know that some of their fans are supporters of President Donald Trump, but Jonathan is not a fan. “I believe our show is about finding solutions for the little guy, and I think the current administration is doing stuff that is counterproductive to serving the little guy,” he said.

Property Brothers programming is now international, on the air in more than 150 countries. The brothers live in a constant cycle of product promotion and never tire of posing for selfies with fans from San Antonio to Singapore, where they were met by thousands when they visited. This was initially a surprise to them, since Asian housing stock and ways of living differ so greatly from those of North America. But, Jonathan pointed out, “Everyone lives somewhere.”

In their hallmark show, “Property Brothers,” Drew, a real estate agent, helps a family buy a new home and Jonathan, a construction contractor, helps them renovate. It is among HGTV’s highest-ranking programs. The last season of “Brother vs. Brother,” which is produced by Scott Brothers Entertainment, drew more than 14 million viewers. These are just two of their HGTV programs.

Their shows are part of a popular HGTV lineup which includes “Flip or Flop,” with Tarek El Moussa and Christina El Moussa, and “Fixer Upper,” with Chip and Joanna Gaines, who appeared on the cover of People magazine last October, before the Scotts’ first cover in April. “No, we’re not jealous of them,” Drew said. “They are phenomenally successful, the audience loves them and our fans have been asking for us to do something together.” The Scotts asked the Gaineses to appear on an episode of “Brother vs. Brother” in Galveston, but they were busy.

The Scott brothers realize that their wholesomeness is the key to their appeal. “It’s safe programming,” Drew said over a gluten-free lunch quickly eaten amid the filming of “Brother vs. Brother.” “The shows are not so foofy that guys don’t want to watch, kids want to watch because we’re goofy and women appreciate it because you’re getting real design knowledge.”

They say they are basically just ordinary folks. “People think because you’re a celebrity, because you’re on TV, because you’re People magazine’s Sexiest Men Alive, things like that, that we’re bathing in champagne and taking limos door to door. But we’re literally the same guys, just with much busier schedules,” Jonathan said, as he drove both brothers back to their respective house-renovation sets in his Chrysler 300.

They do, however, enjoy many perks. Just a few days before Barack Obama left the White House, the brothers took a private tour of the Oval Office and West Wing. (“There is a lot of great character you would want to keep,” Drew said, “but there are a lot of things that are due for an update.”) They recently visited NASA and experienced virtual reality with astronauts. While filming in Galveston, they took in a Houston Rockets game and played Ping-Pong with the team’s general manager.

Jonathan Scott, who has won the competition on the last two seasons of the show. (Todd Spoth for The New York Times)
Jonathan Scott, who has won the competition on the last two seasons of the show. (Todd Spoth for The New York Times)

When they were children, they said, they performed frequently in comedy and improv, and as clowns for hire. The brothers began buying, renovating and flipping real estate when they were 18. The idea was to use real estate as a vehicle to finance careers in entertainment.

In 2009, producers in Canada saw an opportunity to get in on the reality TV real estate boom. The pitch, Jonathan said, was “two good looking guys in tight jeans doing home renovations; we said, ‘Sure, we’ll do that.’ ” The show aired on Canadian cable in 2010 and in 2011 was picked up by HGTV.

Their ambitions go much further than posts and beams.

They would like to do a talk show, and say they have been approached by “several big broadcast networks” but don’t think the timing is right. Jonathan said he was “very into conservation and solar energy.” He has written a documentary series about renewable energy, and would like to write more in the future, moving beyond his usual output of “inspirational things and cheesy things for our fans.”

Drew would like to resume his acting career, but time has been short. He and Jonathan had cameo roles on the USA Network’s “Playing House,” and say they have been offered guest roles on shows like “Castle.”

Together, the brothers have also written two screenplays, which they plan to produce (in addition to their father’s cowboy picture). The first one they would like to make, Jonathan said, is “a dark comedy that follows the life of a professional ‘hook up’ artist as he discovers his own loneliness through the romantic misery of others — it’s kind of like ‘Hitch’ meets ‘The Hangover.’” Another, he added, “is about a band of brothers who come from a small-town upbringing with wholesome values.”

Who might they envision playing the lead roles? Originally Drew envisioned his brother and himself as the stars. But what he really wants to do is direct.