In the 1940s, when Robert Tamblyn was working at Toronto's Eaton Centre department store, he noticed that it had tapped the city's water...
In the 1940s, when Robert Tamblyn was working at Toronto’s Eaton Centre department store, he noticed that it had tapped the city’s water main — illegally — to rig up a system that fanned the chilly water through a network of pipes to cool the women’s-evening-wear department.
It was years before the city’s water commissioner wised up. And years more before Tamblyn had the idea of applying the same concept in a bigger way.
“Air conditioning was a whole new word up here in the 1940s,” said Tamblyn, the engineer many credit with developing an alternative technology — lake-source cooling — in North America.
He has helped devise large-scale, energy-efficient cooling systems for the city of Toronto and Cornell University’s Ithaca, N.Y., campus. The city system, the largest of its kind, began operating last summer.
- Designed in Seattle, this $1 cup could save millions of babies
- Trump, Clinton win Washington state primary
- Reed brother led detectives to bodies believed to be Arlington couple
- Boeing plans hundreds of layoffs in local IT unit
- Your vote counts so little in Tuesday’s primary election, John Oliver joked about it on ‘Last Week Tonight’
Most Read Stories
The first successful citywide venture was set up in Stockholm, Sweden, in 1995, but its capacity is less than half of Toronto’s.
Chilly water tapped
Unlike the department store’s jury-rigged setup, Toronto’s taps directly into the chilly water at the bottom of Lake Ontario.
It works by drawing water from 272 feet below the surface, where temperatures are about 40 degrees Fahrenheit year-round. The coldness of the lake water is transferred via heat exchangers to a separate, closed water supply that loops around downtown Toronto and to participating office towers. Thirty-five buildings have already signed on to the project, including the Hudson’s Bay Co.’s 1 million-square-foot retail outlet and 32-story head office. The company predicts it will save $416,000 a year on energy with the system.
Next year, several legislative buildings will be connected to the network.
Launched by Enwave District Energy, a public-private partnership, the system will be able to cool more than 20 million square feet when it reaches full capacity. Participating buildings can expect to reduce the amount of energy used for cooling by an average of 75 percent, officials said.
Dennis Fotinos, Enwave’s president, said the system will ultimately eliminate 40,000 tons a year of carbon-dioxide emissions that conventional air conditioning would produce and free more than 59 megawatts of electricity from the Ontario power grid. Carbon dioxide is a so-called greenhouse gas that many scientists have linked to global warming.
“The more demands you can take off an already-overburdened power grid in the northeastern U.S. and Ontario through initiatives like this, the less likely you’re going to have power surges that cause blackouts,” Fotinos said. “It’s cheaper to reduce demand than build new supply.”
Conventional air-conditioning systems in high-rise buildings use electrically powered chillers in basements to cool circulating water before pumping it upward and fanning it out over each floor. As the water rises, it absorbs heat, much of which is dissipated into the air by cooling towers on the roof before the water is returned to the basement to repeat the cycle.
With lake-source cooling, the chillers in the basements and cooling towers on the roofs are obsolete. After heat exchangers use the lake water to lower the temperature of the cooling water, a central pumping station sends the cooling water around the city loop, branching off to each building. The cooling water eventually returns to each building’s basement, where other heat exchangers extract some of the heat before sending it back to the pumping station to repeat the cycle.
Drinking water warmed
The project got the green light several years ago, after Toronto residents began complaining about foul drinking water. The city’s water commission gave Enwave permission to tap the lake to fulfill Tamblyn’s vision of a cooling system under a deal that would also bring clean drinking water to the city through the 3.5-mile-long intake pipes.
Enwave’s long pipes draw water from depths untouched by the sun and most contaminants, allowing the city to save on purification. But at 40 degrees, deep-lake water could give people headaches if they drank it directly, and it would cost a small fortune to heat for bathing. The system’s central heat exchangers solve that problem by extracting the coldness from the lake water to cool the air-conditioning supply and then sending the warmed lake water to the city’s drinking-water supply. The cooling-water loop is a closed system, and the two supplies never mix.
At Cornell, W.S. “Lanny” Joyce, the founder of its Lake Source Cooling Project, said the university began looking for alternatives after the 1987 Montreal Protocol restricted the use of chlorofluorocarbons widely used in air-conditioning systems at the time.
“An institutional body like us, we figured we’d be around for at least another 135 years. So we needed a long-term solution,” said Joyce, Cornell’s manager of engineering, planning and energy management.
The university system was designed to last 100 years — typical air conditioners have a life span of 15 to 20 years — to justify the initial investment of $58 million. Since it started in 2000, the project has reduced campus cooling costs by 87 percent.