It has long been a mystery of Aztec arithmetic: What is three arms plus five bones? Now researchers know: Five hearts. The odd symbols had...

Share story

It has long been a mystery of Aztec arithmetic: What is three arms plus five bones?

Now researchers know: Five hearts.

The odd symbols had been noted for centuries; thousands of them appear in Aztec property registries that were created about 1540. But no one knew the value of the symbols or how they were used to represent the size of land plots for tax assessment and other purposes.

After 30 years of work, geographer Barbara Williams and mathematician Maria del Carmen Jorge y Jorge have found a solution that reveals a complex surveying system with a rudimentary ability to calculate the area of irregular shapes and manipulate fractional amounts.

This week, save 90% on digital access.

“It cracks the code,” said Williams, a professor emeritus at the University of Wisconsin.

The researchers, who published their findings in the new issue of the journal Science, based their analysis on two books called the Codex Vergara and the Codice de Santa Maria Asunción. The manuscripts were written on paper brought by the Spanish conquistadors.

The researchers said the property drawings in the books were likely transcribed from even older documents written on tree bark or cotton cloth.

The pages of the books are filled with tiny property maps. For each plot, there are two drawings: one showing the lengths of the sides and another showing the area. The measurements are represented by seven symbols: lines, dots, arrows, hearts, hands, arms and bones. Each map also includes the name of the property owner and the soil type.

Researchers knew what each map represented and the value of some of the measurements. A line, for example, was the standard unit of length, which was known as a “tlaquahuitl,” or rod, and in modern units would measure 2.5 meters (about 8.20 feet).

When the researchers knew the values of the units in roughly rectangular plots, they could easily follow the logic of the Aztecs and reproduce their calculations by multiplying lengths and widths.

But they were stymied in calculating many plots because they didn’t know the value of the units. The breakthrough came when Jorge y Jorge, a professor at the National Autonomous University of Mexico, found that some areas were prime numbers.

That meant some of the unknown symbols had to represent fractions of a rod, she said.

By trial and error, she decoded the system. A hand equaled 3/5 of a rod, an arrow was 1/2, a heart was 2/5, an arm was 1/3, and a bone was 1/5 of a rod.

A set of at least five formulas emerged showing how the Aztec surveyors determined the areas of irregular shapes. In some cases, the Aztecs averaged opposite sides and then multiplied. In others, they bisected the fields into triangles.

Of the 369 plots the researchers examined, they could accurately reproduce the Aztec math in 287 cases, according to the study.

Still, Williams and Jorge y Jorge don’t understand how the Aztec surveyors decided which formula to use for each area calculation.

Custom-curated news highlights, delivered weekday mornings.