The websites Pintester and CraftFail poke fun at Pinterest-inspired craft failures.

Share story

CONCORD, N.H. — For the aspiring cooks and crafters who frequent, “pinning” something is one thing. “Nailing” it is another.

By letting users create “virtual pinboards,” Pinterest has become a popular way to keep track of home-decor ideas, recipes and craft projects spread across the Internet. But those who go beyond collecting pretty pictures and actually attempt to re-create the crafts often discover it’s harder than it looks.

Such failures are featured to humorous effect on at least two sites, including and As the name implies, the former chronicle’s one woman’s dogged attempts to replicate recipes, fashion, beauty products and craft ideas she spots on Pinterest. The latter, which was launched before Pinterest existed, accepts submissions from anyone who has tried, and failed, at crafting of any kind.

Heather Mann, of Salem, Ore., started CraftFail as a place to post her own failed projects. From her early posts about handmade soap that resembled Spam (“when you want to wash your hands with what appears to be potted meat”), the site has attracted hundreds of entries from fellow crafters willing to poke fun at themselves. Pinterest is now often the inspiration, or culprit, she said.

Unlimited Digital Access. $1 for 4 weeks.

“With the popularity of Pinterest, a lot of new, inexperienced people are trying crafting. They see something on Pinterest that they like and they want to re-create it, and when they do, it doesn’t turn out the way they wanted it to,” she said.

As on, the not-so-perfect pictures are often labeled with the tagline, “NAILED IT.” But unlike Mann, Pintester’s Sonja Foust is decidedly un-crafty. Some readers have complained she’d have more success if she used the correct ingredients or materials.

“But this is how I really do it, even if I wasn’t publishing it on a blog,” she said. “It’s not that I’m doing it just for the cheap laughs; I’m just really bad at this stuff.”

Even when she follows instructions, failure is common. Take the “Strawberries and Cream Mug Cake.” The original version from‘s The Family Kitchen blog shows a single serving of cake tucked into a dainty white mug, topped with a swirl of whipped cream and a scattering of strawberries. Foust’s blog shows a lumpy, spongy mess she pried out of the mug with a spoon.

“I was pretty surprised and sort of torn between being disappointed that it didn’t turn out and delighted that it was going to make a good blog post,” said Foust, who lives in Durham, N.C., and writes romance novels in addition to her blog.

Despite her admitted lack of skills, Foust said she frequently attempted to make recipes and crafts she saw on Pinterest even before she had her blog.

“I have this disease where I look at something and think, ‘Oh, that looks really easy, I can do that!’ ” she joked.

Custom-curated news highlights, delivered weekday mornings.