Columnist Carolyn Hax offers advice to a woman wondering if it's normal that her boyfriend can't say "I love you."
DEAR CAROLYN: I have been in a relationship with a guy (I’m 43 and he’s 39) for five years now, and he has never told me he loves me.
About two years ago or so, I asked him if he loved me, and his answer was along the lines of “What does love mean?” I almost lost it. I was like, “What do you mean, ‘What does love mean?’ “
I went into the reasons I loved him, and he still couldn’t tell me he loved me.
- Amazon rolls out free same-day delivery for Prime members
- They were millionaires for 3 months, but Seattle couple didn't know it
- Marymoor Park concerts: Full lineup announced
- Capitol Hill light-rail station nearly ready for trains to rumble
- Nelson Cruz's home run in ninth inning lifts Mariners to sweep of Rays
Most Read Stories
I know he has been in love before. He told me he was in love with his past two girlfriends. I feel like a fool that I have stuck around for two more years hoping to finally hear those words.
He was badly hurt in his last relationship (she cheated on him) so there are major trust issues that we have had to endure over the past five years. I keep thinking that is why he can’t tell me he loves me. Maybe it is just time for me to move on. Is this normal?
DEAR ANONYMOUS: I think it’s possible to drive yourself mad trying to figure out what “should” happen, what’s “normal,” and possible reasons you have X vs. Y, when really the only relevant question is: Am I happy in this relationship as-is, or am I waiting for something to change?
If it’s the former, yea, you can relieve yourself of the burden of Figuring It All Out.
If it’s the latter, and if you’ve clearly spelled out for him what you’re waiting for, and if you have gone a decent stretch of time without seeing any effort or progress toward the thing you’re waiting for, then it’s time to admit to yourself it’s not coming anytime soon.
Then you need to ask yourself — and answer without rationalizing: “Can I be happy in this relationship without it?” If no, then it’s time to go.
Think of this as the flow chart of frustrated love.
Re: “He was badly hurt”: Oh, good God. You know, of all the times I’ve ever read this excuse, it has hardly ever been true. Why can’t people just be more honest? “I don’t feel it.” “I wish I cared for you that way, but I don’t.” What’s so difficult about this? And then why STAY in those relationships?
— Anonymous 2
DEAR ANONYMOUS 2: Also, for the sake of argument, let’s say that occasionally it does turn out to be true: If you’re still that emotionally injured by a past relationship, then what are you doing in another relationship?
Sure, yes, people will always have their Stuff, and it’s normal for each half of a couple to bring vulnerabilities to the mix. But if the needing and nurturing and Stuff-related reassurances are flowing only one way, or flowing at a high volume, then it’s not a relationship, it’s a mutual dependency, where a need to be fussed over pairs up with a need to fuss.
Find her columns daily at www.seattletimes.com