Neuroscientists say that what happened to Texas Gov. Rick Perry Wednesday night was a common malady, exacerbated by stress: a "retrieval failure."
It was the Hoover Dam of mental blocks. Rick Perry called it a “brain freeze.” Pundits referred to it as a “gaffe.” In Internet parlance, it was an “epic FAIL.”
But to neuroscientists, what happened to the Texas governor Wednesday night looked like something very ordinary, exacerbated by stress: a “retrieval failure.”
It happens more often as we age. But the scientists say it shouldn’t be seen as evidence of an intellectual deficit or some medical problem.
- Mariners fire general manager Jack Zduriencik
- Now comes the hard part for the Mariners: Hiring Jack Zduriencik’s replacement
- Wet weekend ahead, with high winds and heavy rain expected
- Mariners demote struggling catcher Mike Zunino
- Animated map: How the wildfires in North Central Washington have grown over time
Most Read Stories
Instead, they say, retrieval failures offer a glimpse into how the brain does and doesn’t work, not just in the skulls of presidential candidates but for everyone else, too.
It’s impossible to know what exactly was happening inside Perry’s head at the Republican presidential debate, and the pundits will continue to debate whether it was a neurological hiccup or a telling sign of a candidate who doesn’t know his own policies.
What’s certain is that, at a crucial moment, on stage, live on national television, Perry could not remember the name of one of the federal agencies he would like to abolish.
Once he started to struggle, he probably found himself entangled with unhelpful thoughts, suggested David Diamond, a behavioral neuroscientist at the University of South Florida. In a stressful moment like this, the mind turns to the consequences of the error, making an elegant recovery all the harder.
“Even though Rick Perry’s life was not being threatened, his brain was responding as if there was a lion in the audience about to pounce on him,” Diamond said. “He’s now got the media pouncing on him.”
Not only problem
The governor’s mental lapse did not occur in a vacuum. His previous debate performances have been widely panned, and he has been sliding in the polls, fighting a perception that he’s not up to the job.
He was speaking Wednesday to an informed audience, one capable of understanding the nuances of policy. But he struggled with a talking point, opening himself to criticism that he doesn’t have the depth of knowledge expected of a presidential candidate.
It was unclear Thursday whether his candidacy could survive his blunder. But among brain scientists, at least, he’s getting a pass.
Jason Brandt, a professor of psychiatry and neurology at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, said he’s a die-hard Democrat but wouldn’t hold Perry’s flub against him:
“I think it’s unfortunate that it happened in a situation of such high visibility. Brain freeze. Brain fart. Whatever you want to call it, they happen, and happen at times of high anxiety in particular.”
Such mental blocks often involve the failure to retrieve a proper noun, the experts said. A proper noun is like a label: It represents a more complex concept.
Patients with recurring, pathological problems retrieving a label are said to suffer from anomia. But it’s something that happens to everyone occasionally.
It happened to Perry in a brutal fashion. For the better part of a minute during the GOP debate in Rochester, Mich., Perry tried to come up with a word: “Energy.” It was the third word in a list of three federal agencies he says he’d close if elected president.
But although he named the Commerce and Education departments, he couldn’t quite snag that third word from wherever it was hiding in his brain.
He pointed at his own head and laughed. Another candidate suggested he was thinking of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and Perry momentarily seized on that.
But moderator John Harwood asked, “Seriously? Is EPA the one you were talking about?”
Perry acknowledged t it wasn’t.
“But you can’t name the third one?” Harwood said.
Perry made another spirited lunge at it. “I would do away with the Education, the Commerce and, let’s see. … “
Retrieval failure, again.
The governor despaired.
“I can’t. The third one, I can’t. Sorry. Oops.”
It would be the oops heard ’round the political world.
Diamond said the brain’s structure is partly to blame for a retrieval error. Language centers are not particularly close to memory centers; it’s like New Jersey trying to communicate with China.
Diamond said retrieval failures often involve new information. In Perry’s case, he has been governor of Texas for more than a decade, but has been running for president for only a few months.
“When we forget words, when we forget names, it is new information that has just not established strong links in our brain,” Diamond said.
And yes, it’s getting worse for all of us, he said. That’s not just because some of us are getting into the more advanced age brackets, where the brain literally shrinks and the rust metaphorically builds up, but because we’re increasingly saturated with information.
“We are doing so much now, we’re multitasking perhaps at a higher degree than ever before,” Diamond said. “We get into work, and we’re handling emails, we’re going to all the websites, we’re processing more information now than ever before. We’re asking more of our brains than evolution ever prepared us to handle. So every now and then, we just drop the ball.”
MIT neuroscientist John Gabrieli stresses that a retrieval failure is due to a mental block that has to be cleared away, somehow, before you can find the word you want.
“It’s not that you can’t get there, it’s that something’s blocking that, some other idea or word has come into your head. Until you clear that other thing, it’s hard to get back to that piece of information that you really know,” Gabrieli said.
Aileen Pincus of the Washington-based Pincus Group, which coaches people on public speaking, said a good rule for speakers is to avoid lists. Even a shortlist, such as the one Perry tried to offer, can be a trap.
“It was self-entrapment,” she said. And when Perry failed the first time, “he started the list again.”
Brandt counsels people who worry about memory slips to relax, go on to something else and wait. The memory will resurface soon enough.
“The more you try to focus on it, the deeper your hole gets,” he said.
But that common-sense strategy wasn’t an option for Perry. When he couldn’t find the word “energy,” he couldn’t just say, “whatever.”
All he could do was twist in his deepening hole.