When Holly Smith bought Cafe Juanita from Peter Dow in 2000, it was a popular, 20-year-old Italian restaurant in an out-of-the-way Kirkland neighborhood. Dow said to her then, “Holly, you’re going to take this to the next level.”
Almost immediately, she did, earning 3½ stars from Nancy Leson in this newspaper that same year, gathering accolades from the national press, and winning the James Beard Award for Best Chef Northwest in 2008.
Smith has unequivocally made Cafe Juanita her own, gaining confidence as a proprietor and maturing as a chef. Early on, she weaned diners from Dow’s “pollo ai pistacchi,” turning them on to rabbit braised in Arneis wine, an extraordinary dish she doesn’t dare take off the menu.
That card remains familiar but far from fixed. Pasta, made fresh daily, takes different shapes with different sauces. Snails with basil, garlic and breadcrumbs have lately turned up among little ears of orecchiette that now also come in a gluten-free version tasting very close to the original. (Vegan, vegetarian and dairy-free menus are available, as well.)
- As USS Ranger departs, Navy's cost dilemma takes off
- Seahawks courting a pair of cornerbacks as free agency looms
- UW tops new list of best western universities
- Seattle's micro-housing boom offers an affordable alternative
- Live updates from the state boys basketball tournament
Most Read Stories
Dishes track the seasons. Though the cooking leans toward Northern Italian richness, flavors are from all over the Boot, and ingredients might come from anywhere.
Australian Wagyu beef made a spectacular carne cruda. The heavily marbled raw meat, coarsely chopped and mixed with finely minced shallot, lemon zest and a pinch of cayenne, is served with crostini, some topped with thin sheets of house-cured lardo.
Ligurian olive oil, almond milk foam and colatura, a potent Southern Italian fish sauce, anointed yellowtail cruda, surrounded by coriander leaves, slivered snap peas and crisp puffed rice grains dusted with bottarga, the salt-cured mullet roe prevalent in Sicily.
Goat-cheese gnocchi no bigger than the tip of a pinkie nestled amid fava beans and crackling shards of guanciale (pork jowl bacon), sauced sparingly with an intense reduction of butter, olive oil, aromatics, wine and brodo, a complex broth that is a key ingredient in Smith’s arsenal.
Brodo bolstered a creamy risotto infused with squash blossoms, as well as the lusty lentils supporting crisp-skinned Muscovy duck breast. It enriched the demi-glace accompanying rosemary-scented, grilled lamb chops, and it is the foundation of Smith’s ever-changing, always astonishing “zuppa della sera.”
Oregon black cod, a recent “pesce della sera,” rode a fuchsia wave of beet crema, a thick, whipped emulsion of beets and olive oil that incredibly contains no cream. She repeats that trick coupling pistachio crema with seared foie gras.
When rich meets richer, a sharp counterbalance is essential. With the fish, it was a panzanella salad of rye bread, radish and arugula. With the cauliflower, it was cumin, cayenne and a spritz of lime.
With the foie gras, it was the sweet and bitter mingling of Bing cherries, ginger and crunchy cacao nibs. That dish came with a side of pan juices begging to be mopped up with herbed focaccia from an array of house-baked breads and crackers.
Was that extra just for me, I wondered? As a longtime customer, I am not unknown here, but everyone gets the drippings, just as everyone enjoys the attention of servers who work with practiced synchrony.
Anyone also may request wine pairings with each course, as I did. Wine director Kyle Brierley was savvy in his choices and didn’t play it safe. With a pungent salad of lacy Ruby Streaks mustard greens, he poured Menabrea Doppio Malto Rosso, a dark Piedmont beer with the right robustness for the greens’ horseradish bite and anchovy vinaigrette. He willingly poured half glasses, too, which helps keep the cost down and the head clear.
Anna Ivers’ desserts (like her breads and crackers) rise to the high standards of everything else. Perfect vanilla panna cotta quivered beside a pool of Tuscan honey. Invigorating espresso granita accompanied tiramisu leggero that was indeed light.
From aperitivi served with matching little bites to dainty biscotti, Cafe Juanita maintains a level of excellence rare in these parts. Food and service deserve four stars. But the Riedel stemware and fresh flowers can’t disguise that the 62-year-old house “needs some love,” as Smith says. Soon it will get some. Fourteen years ago, Smith bought the business; now she’s buying the property. Plans call for an expansion by spring 2015 that will include a full bar and other upgrades. A fourth star should be within reach then.
Providence Cicero is The Seattle Times restaurant critic; email@example.com.